|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| September 1981 |
|
|
A conviction based solely on the uncorroborated testimony of a co-accused is unsafe and was quashed.
Criminal law – conviction based on co-accused’s testimony – requirement for corroboration; circumstantial evidence; documentary proof (signatures on receipts); reasonable doubt; unsafe conviction quashed.
|
30 September 1981 |
|
Appeal allowed: dissolution set aside where cruelty and desertion allegations were unproven and statutory referral was absent.
Matrimonial law – requirement of referral to Marriage Conciliatory Board (s.101) before court may consider matrimonial complaints; cruelty – allegation of refusal to have sexual intercourse not entertainable without prior referral; cruelty – refusal to cook/food contamination must be proved; desertion – statutory three-year requirement (s.107(e)); petty quarrels do not justify divorce.
|
29 September 1981 |
|
A plaintiff cannot claim an unpleaded higher rental balance at trial without amending the plaint; appeal dismissed with costs.
Civil procedure – pleadings and amendment – plaintiff cannot recover an unpleaded higher sum introduced at trial without applying to amend the plaint. Pleadings – arithmetic consistency – the pleaded amounts and admitted payments determine claimable balance. Evidence – late attempts to vary pleaded claim treated as afterthought and properly rejected by trial court.
|
26 September 1981 |
|
Repudiation of a customary familial relationship does not defeat a person’s inheritance claim to property acquired under that custom.
Customary succession – matrilineal to patrilineal shift – effect on inheritance rights Family status – recognition of someone treated as a son by the inheritor – entitlement to inherited property Repudiation of customary familial ties – cannot defeat a beneficiary’s claim to property acquired under that custom
|
26 September 1981 |
|
Application to set aside an ex parte appellate judgment dismissed where counsel had notice and failed to exercise reasonable diligence.
Civil procedure – setting aside ex parte appellate judgment – Order IX r.13 inapplicable to appellate judgments; Order XXXIX not directly applicable to appeals dismissed in appellant’s absence; availability of further appeal; duty of counsel to exercise reasonable diligence; proof of notice and failure to file counter-affidavit.
|
25 September 1981 |
|
A child born during a subsisting marriage is presumed legitimate and the husband is presumed father despite marital separation.
Family law – Presumption of legitimacy; marriage presumed to subsist until dissolved by court; separation by one spouse walking out does not dissolve marriage; child born during coverture presumed to be husband’s; access rights.
|
25 September 1981 |
|
Appellate court restores trial court's finding on cattle seizure, holding trial court best placed to assess witness credibility.
Civil procedure – execution and objection proceedings; evidentiary weight and credibility assessments – trial court best placed to evaluate witness credibility; appellate interference only where trial findings are unreasonable.
|
24 September 1981 |
|
Allocation of a plot conveys trees standing on it; appellant's compensation claim dismissed, remedy lies with allocating authority.
Land law — allocation of village plot — fixtures and standing trees form part of the land and pass with the plot; remedy for disputed allocation lies with the allocating authority, not by suing for compensation against the allottee.
|
23 September 1981 |
|
Appeal against robbery with violence conviction dismissed due to credible eyewitness identification in daylight.
Criminal law – Robbery with violence – Sufficiency of evidence – Eyewitness identification in daylight – Credibility of complainant and other witnesses – Non-testimony of arresting villagers not fatal to prosecution.
|
22 September 1981 |
|
Customary mkamona fostering can ground a compensation claim for upkeep of a child; appellate court restored entitlement but reduced the award.
Customary law – mkamona fostering relationship – maintenance and upbringing obligations where child left in caregiver’s custody after relationship terminates. Civil procedure – appellate review of factual findings – where appellate court must not reverse trial findings without proper investigation of evidence. Quantum – substitution of customary cattle award with monetary equivalent to reflect period of care.
|
22 September 1981 |
|
Equitable care and testamentary evidence can defeat customary heirs; an intentional fatal head blow constitutes manslaughter and warrants imprisonment.
Civil law – inheritance/customary succession – equitable relief and testamentary evidence may defeat claims of absent customary heirs; caretaker’s contributions and prior bequest persuasive. Criminal law – unlawful striking causing fatal skull fracture – conduct may amount to manslaughter; plea accepted and six-year sentence imposed.
|
21 September 1981 |
|
An honest belief in paternity is a defence to child-stealing under section 169, leading to quashing of conviction.
Criminal law – Child-stealing (s.169 Penal Code) – Defence of claim of right – Honest belief of paternity by accused constitutes a lawful defence; paternity determination is civil, not criminal.
|
21 September 1981 |
|
Appeal dismissed; appellate court upheld valuation of a lost watch and ordered payment of Shs. 1,000.
Civil procedure – appeals on questions of fact – assessment of value of lost property – appellate courts should not interfere with factual valuation unless record shows misapprehension or lack of evidence.
|
21 September 1981 |
|
Appeal dismissed; convictions for impersonation, extortion by menaces, theft, unlawful confinement, assault and disorderly conduct upheld.
Criminal law – Identification evidence – daytime prolonged contact supporting reliability; Impersonation of police officer; Menaces and extortion – threats causing fear and inducing payment; Theft by means of menaces; Unlawful arrest and false imprisonment; Assault occasioning actual bodily harm; Disorderly conduct at police station (use of weapon, abuse of officers).
|
21 September 1981 |
|
Circumstantial evidence must exclude all reasonable hypotheses of innocence; here reasonable doubt compelled acquittal.
Criminal law — Theft — Circumstantial evidence — Standard of proof: must exclude every reasonable hypothesis of innocence — Unexplained open window and absence of forcible entry give rise to reasonable doubt — Initial inconsistency in complainant's report insufficient to establish guilt.
|
21 September 1981 |
|
Earlier judgment fixing boundary barred appellant's later suit as res judicata; appeal dismissed with costs.
Civil procedure – res judicata – earlier judgment dividing land and fixing boundary – subsequent suit to vary boundary barred as res judicata.
|
19 September 1981 |
|
Insufficient evidence that respondent enticed the appellant’s wife; appeal dismissed with costs.
Family law – Enticement of spouse – Proof required to establish enticement; credibility and identification of accused where multiple persons present; appellate review of factual findings.
|
18 September 1981 |
|
Killing held accidental, provocation not established; accused conditionally discharged for 12 months.
Criminal law – Homicide: murder versus accidental killing – Provocation – Weight of extra‑judicial statements and eyewitness evidence – Conditional discharge/sentence.
|
18 September 1981 |
|
High Court set aside dismissal for non-incorporation of amended plaint, restored suit, and directed it be heard on merits.
Civil procedure – Stay of execution – Order 39 Rule 5 Civil Procedure Code – normally to be applied to court which passed decree; Revisional jurisdiction – section 79 Civil Procedure Code – setting aside order dismissing suit for material irregularity where amended plaint had been filed but not reflected in record; Restoration of suit and hearing on merits.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
Appellate court upheld lower courts: respondent proved ownership of disputed developed land; appeal dismissed with costs.
Land law – ownership of developed land; evaluation of oral testimony and witness credibility; appellate review of concurrent findings of fact.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
Insufficient identification of alleged goats defeated the respondent's claim for damages; appeal allowed and suit dismissed.
Civil liability for stray animals – proof of ownership/identification of animals; insufficiency of vague witness testimony; appellate intervention where identification not proved; trespass/damage claims against livestock.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
Appeal allowed: identification and date discrepancies created reasonable doubt, convictions for cattle theft quashed.
Criminal law – circumstantial evidence – identification of stolen property – description discrepancies (colour) and inconsistent dates – proof beyond reasonable doubt – benefit of doubt to accused.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
Court upheld divorce where impotence, extramarital conception and lack of maintenance showed irreparable marital breakdown.
Family law – Divorce – Irreparable breakdown of marriage – Impotence, extramarital conception and failure to maintain – Primary Court factual findings upheld on appeal.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
A court cannot compel a spouse to cohabit; prolonged desertion may justify dissolution under Law of Marriage Act s.140.
Matrimonial law; Law of Marriage Act 1971 s.140; prohibition on compelling cohabitation; desertion; irretrievable/irreparable breakdown as ground for dissolution.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
A woman cohabiting two years has statutory rights to matrimonial assets; tribal custom cannot defeat the Marriage Act.
Family law – division of matrimonial assets; Law of Marriage Act No. 5 of 1971 (s.160) overrides tribal custom; entitlement of woman cohabiting two years or more to share jointly acquired assets; requirement for courts to state adequate reasons and valuation criteria in asset division.
|
17 September 1981 |
|
The appellant's denial failed; credible evidence of uprooted maize upheld the respondent's Shs.500 award.
Civil law – damage to crops – proof on balance of probabilities by oral evidence; appellate review of factual findings; Primary Court must assess evidence, not be distracted by parties' personal relationship; award of damages for crop destruction.
|
16 September 1981 |
|
Accused acquitted because eyewitness identification in a crowded nighttime scene was unreliable, creating reasonable doubt.
Criminal law – Murder – Identification evidence – reliability of eyewitnesses related to deceased – nighttime crowded scene – failure to arrest – reasonable doubt – acquittal.
|
16 September 1981 |
|
Failure to refer the matrimonial dispute to the conciliatory board rendered the petitioner’s divorce petition incompetent; respondent awarded custody.
Family law – Law of Marriage Act 1971 s.101 – mandatory referral to conciliatory board and admissibility/authenticity of board certificate; desertion as ground for divorce; insufficiency of evidence for adultery; child custody — best interests, effect of parental misconduct (kidnapping).
|
15 September 1981 |
|
Appellate court upheld findings that seized cattle belonged to the judgment debtor and dismissed the appeal with costs.
Execution of decree – seizure of property in possession of third party – ownership versus possession – appellate review of concurrent findings of fact.
|
15 September 1981 |
|
Where evidence showed 31 cattle seized against a 30-cow bridewealth, respondent must return one cow.
Family law – bridewealth refund – dispute over number of cattle reclaimed; credibility of village chairman's seizure evidence; remedy where one cow taken in excess.
|
14 September 1981 |
|
Daylight identification and recent-possession evidence upheld convictions for cattle theft; appeal dismissed.
Criminal law – Cattle theft – Identification and recent possession – Recent-possession of stolen property as evidence of theft; identification in daylight by witnesses who knew accused; prior inconsistent statements – hostile witness and impeachment only; alibi – bare denial insufficient to raise reasonable doubt; sentence – statutory minimum upheld.
|
11 September 1981 |
|
|
11 September 1981 |
|
Convictions based on a 13‑year‑old’s evidence without a voir dire are unsafe and require corroboration; convictions quashed.
Criminal law – evidence – child of tender years – voir dire required to ascertain understanding of oath – omission renders testimony unsworn – uncorroborated evidence of child insufficient to sustain conviction; statutory requirement to record voir dire findings and distinction from cases where judge recorded understanding.
|
11 September 1981 |
|
Conviction based on a child of tender years improperly sworn without voir dire is unsustainable absent independent corroboration.
Evidence Act s.127 – child of tender years – competency to testify – requirement to interview and record contents when determining competency. Voir dire – necessity to determine whether child understands nature/effect of oath; omission reduces sworn evidence to unsworn status. Child witness – uncorroborated evidence of child of tender years cannot sustain conviction. Criminal procedure – conviction quashed and retrial ordered where child evidence improperly received.
|
11 September 1981 |
Evidence - Evidence of a child of tender years - voire dire examination -Effect of omission to conduct it before swearing in a child of tender years. |
11 September 1981 |
|
Appeal dismissed; possession defence rejected and compensation for eight cattle reserved until appellant is summoned.
Criminal law – possession defence discredited by overwhelming evidence; compensation for victims – court may order compensation under statutory provision but proviso bars doing so in accused's absence; procedural requirement to summon accused to show cause before making compensation order.
|
11 September 1981 |
|
Appellate court improperly overturned trial court credibility findings and wrongly held claim time-barred; cause of action accrues on demand and refusal.
Civil procedure – appellate review of credibility findings – trial court better placed to assess witnesses’ credibility; appellate court should not lightly overturn those findings. Limitation of actions – Limitation of Proceedings under Customary Law Rules 1964 (Limitation Act No.10/71) – accrual of cause of action for return of bailed property occurs on demand and refusal, not on date of bailment. Possession and bailment – remedy for recovery of bailed goods and accounting for proceeds from sale of bailed property.
|
11 September 1981 |
|
Appellant’s denial of knowledge rejected; appeal dismissed for failure to rebut evidence proving respondent's ownership of five cattle.
Civil recovery – movable property (cattle) – proof of ownership and possession – witness identification and corroboration – appellate interference with concurrent factual findings.
|
10 September 1981 |
|
Accused convicted of manslaughter for fatally striking deceased during a fight and sentenced to six years.
Criminal law – Manslaughter vs murder – fatal blow during fight; taking law into own hands; self‑defence claim; sentencing of first offender.
|
10 September 1981 |
|
Appeal against severity of sentence dismissed; late mitigation raised on appeal rejected and concurrent two‑year terms confirmed.
Criminal law – Stealing by agent – Sentencing – Mitigation – Late‑raised explanations at appeal treated as afterthoughts; appellate interference with sentence refused where trial court’s sentencing was reasonable – Confirmation of sentences required by High Court.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
The applicant's convictions for possession of suspected stolen property and corrupt transaction were upheld and sentences affirmed.
Criminal law – Possession of suspected stolen property – s.312(1)(a) Penal Code – sufficiency of evidence to support conviction. Criminal law – Corrupt transaction with an agent – s.3(2)(a) Prevention of Corruption Act No.26 of 1971 – evidence of offering money to police. Sentencing – Minimum Sentences Act – application and appropriateness; concurrent sentences.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
Lower courts rightly accepted witness evidence of bailment of seven cattle; appeal dismissed with costs.
Civil law – Bailment and recovery of chattels – Credibility of witness evidence – Appellate review of factual findings – Acceptance of primary court’s credibility determinations.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
One appellant’s convictions were quashed for insufficient evidence; the other’s convictions were upheld based on recovered stolen property.
Criminal law – Sufficiency of evidence – housebreaking and stealing – possession/recovery of identifiable stolen goods – effect of delay between theft and recovery – appellate review of vague or poorly recorded trial proceedings.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
Convictions quashed where magistrate denied alibi witness, misdirected on burden and identification evidence was weak.
Criminal law – robbery with violence – identification evidence – arrests on suspicion – absence of identification parade – alibi – right to call witnesses – improper burden on accused – unsafe conviction.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
Appellants' robbery convictions quashed due to denial of defence witness opportunity and weak identification evidence.
Criminal law – robbery with violence – alibi – accused’s right to call defence witnesses – burden of proof – misdirection by trial magistrate – identification evidence – absence of arresting officer’s evidence and identification parade – unsafe conviction – appeal allowed.
|
9 September 1981 |
|
Applicant failed to prove cruelty under section 107(1)(c); judicial separation and maintenance application dismissed with costs.
Matrimonial law – Judicial separation – Requirement of cruelty under section 107(1)(c) of the Law of Marriage Act, 1971 – Need for evidence of mental or physical cruelty; Ancillary relief – Maintenance contingent on grant of judicial separation; Procedural – Repetitive or unsubstantiated litigation following prior unsuccessful divorce proceedings.
|
8 September 1981 |
|
Divorce on respondent's alleged incurable mental illness refused; appellant's conduct caused breakdown and maintenance ordered.
Family law – Divorce – Ground of incurable mental illness – Compliance with section 107(2)(h) – Failure to meet statutory requirements bars relief. Family law – Irretrievable breakdown – Court may consider overall conduct; breakdown caused or aggravated by applicant disentitles relief. Family law – Maintenance – Obligation to maintain spouse even if cohabitation is refused.
|
8 September 1981 |
|
A village cannot expropriate occupied land without compensating improvements, but the respondent’s land was not restored due to different village membership.
Jurisdiction of Primary Courts over village land disputes; village allocation of registered-village land; requirement to compensate for improvements and crops when land is reallocated; refusal to restore land to non-member claimant.
|
8 September 1981 |
|
Primary and District Courts had jurisdiction; village wrongly allocated cultivated land without paying compensation; appeal dismissed and compensation ordered.
Land law – village-allotted land and Primary Court jurisdiction – Village (Registration, Designation and Administration) Act No.21 of 1975 – distinction between land allocated to a registered village and land registered under the Land Registration Ordinance; Compensation – obligation to pay for improvements, crops and labour where village allocation/expropriation occurs; Restoration – membership of registered village relevant to entitlement to village land; Evidence – factual findings on crops and absence of criminal conviction affirmed.
|
8 September 1981 |
|
Cattle lawfully transferred to the respondent as bridewealth could not be seized in execution for the transferor's debts; appeal dismissed.
Civil procedure – execution against goods – goods validly transferred to a third party as bridewealth are not liable to satisfy the transferor's debts; levy on third-party property unlawful.
|
8 September 1981 |