|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| January 1988 |
|
Economic Crimes - Unlawful possession of Government Property - Whether an economic crime. Statutory interpretation - Meaning of “dealing ” - Economic and Organized Crime Control Act, 1984, Wildlife Conservation Act, 1974 |
30 January 1988 |
|
Appellants' convictions for robbery upheld on reliable identification evidence; sentence under Minimum Sentences Act affirmed.
Criminal law – Robbery with violence – Identification evidence – Visual identification by complainant and eye-witnesses at night under moonlight and prior acquaintance. Evidence – Credibility – Deference to trial magistrate’s opportunity to observe witnesses and make credibility findings. Sentencing – Minimum Sentences Act, 1972 – Sentence upheld as not excessive.
|
30 January 1988 |
|
Landlord’s unlawful locking of tenant’s workshop gave rise to damages, but claimed quantum was reduced by the court.
Landlord/tenant — unlawful self-help by locking tenant’s premises — wrongful interference with business — assessment of damages for short-term closure — quantum disputed.
|
30 January 1988 |
|
Landlord’s unlawful padlocking of tenant’s workshop warrants damages; court awarded nominal compensation after reducing exaggerated claim.
Landlord unlawfully padlocked tenant’s business premises; self-help improper — remedy is legal process or police; damages for loss of business must be reasonably proven and can be estimated by court; nominal damages awarded for seven-day unlawful closure.
|
30 January 1988 |
|
Plaintiff proved wrongful seizure and conversion of 305 cattle and two goats; defendants liable except the deceased ninth defendant.
Tort — Conversion — Wrongful taking, parting with and retention of goods — Possession and taking can each found conversion. Evidence — Credibility — Court may prefer forthright eyewitness evidence over rehearsed, uncorroborated defence testimony. Complicity — Participation in ordering or promoting unlawful seizure exposes non‑possessory participants to tort liability. Voluntariness — Confessions or purported refunds obtained after assault/torture are involuntary and of no effect.
|
29 January 1988 |
|
Failure to comply with mandatory section 23(1) criminal‑procedure safeguards renders a trial a nullity and mandates retrial.
Criminal procedure – Section 23(1) Criminal Procedure Act – Mandatory requirement to explain charge and inform accused of right to give evidence and call witnesses – Non‑compliance renders trial a nullity – Quashing of proceedings and order for retrial before different magistrate.
|
29 January 1988 |
|
Conviction quashed where identification of commonly traded goods was insufficient and recent possession not proved.
Criminal law – shop‑breaking and stealing – identification of stolen goods – recent possession doctrine – lapse of time and commonly traded items – insufficiency of mere resemblance and receipts – requirement of proof beyond reasonable doubt.
|
29 January 1988 |
Criminal Practice and Procedure - Jurisdiction - Accused duly convicted and sentenced to J2 years imprisonment by Court of Resident Magistrate - Whethers. 170(2) ofCriminal Procedure D Act, 1985 confers sentencing powers ofHigh Court on Resident Magistrates. |
29 January 1988 |
|
Employee convicted for altering luggage receipts and pocketing proceeds; convictions and five-year sentence upheld on appeal.
Criminal law – theft/fraud by employee – issuing altered receipts and under-remitting funds to employer – documentary and handwriting evidence. Evidence – handwriting expert and cashbook corroboration supporting authorship and misappropriation. Sentencing – Minimum Sentences Act 1972; discretion to impose sentence above statutory minimum where appropriate.
|
29 January 1988 |
|
A voluntary oral confession corroborated by circumstantial evidence and co‑accused statements can sustain a robbery conviction.
Criminal law – Robbery with violence – Admissibility of oral confessions – Voluntariness – Use of co-accused confessions as corroborative, not sole, basis for conviction – Circumstantial identification evidence (property identification) – Flight as corroborative evidence – Sentence: statutory minimum.
|
28 January 1988 |
|
|
28 January 1988 |
|
Convictions based on weak, possibly compromised identification evidence were unsafe and were quashed.
Criminal law – Identification evidence – Reliability of visual identification where witness had been blindfolded and later identified accused – Need for corroboration and scrutiny of possible motive or collusion among witnesses – Convictions unsafe where identity not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
|
25 January 1988 |
|
Appeals allowed; burglary and theft convictions quashed for failure to prove breaking, time and stolen status of goods.
Criminal law – Burglary: must prove breaking and that offence occurred at night; proof of locked premises or broken entry required. Theft: sale or possession of goods not ipso facto proof they were stolen. Circumstantial evidence and suspicion alone insufficient to sustain conviction. Appeal – convictions quashed for lack of evidence.
|
21 January 1988 |
|
Where the recipient of a sting payment was not deceived, only an attempt to obtain by false pretences was established.
Criminal law – Obtaining by false pretences – requirement that the recipient be deceived and induced to part with property – where recipient (police in a sting) does not believe representation, only attempt is committed – conviction substituted and sentence reduced.
|
20 January 1988 |
|
Victim identification by lantern light and prior familiarity upheld; appeals against robbery convictions dismissed.
Criminal law – Identification – Victim identification by lantern light and prior familiarity – Adequacy of opportunity to observe. Criminal law – Credibility – Victim testimony corroborated by other witness and subsequent events (injuries, village inquiry, later arrest). Appeals – Conviction and sentence upheld where identification and credibility are satisfactory.
|
19 January 1988 |
|
Conviction based on speculation rather than evidence is unsafe and is set aside; appellant ordered released.
Criminal law – Circumstantial evidence and speculation – Conviction cannot rest on conjecture; findings must be founded on proved facts – Onus on prosecution to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
|
19 January 1988 |
|
Robbery conviction substituted for assault on a police officer; theft intent not proven.
Criminal law — robbery with violence — requirement of intent to permanently deprive — taking during resistance to arrest does not necessarily prove theft; Criminal law — assault of police officer — acts in resisting arrest may constitute assault on officer in execution of duty; Duplicity — overlap of counts and proper characterisation of offence.
|
18 January 1988 |
|
Appeal against conviction for attempted robbery dismissed; identification and physical evidence sufficient and sentence not excessive.
Criminal law – Attempted robbery with firearm – Identification evidence (identity parade and in‑court recognition) – Credibility of witnesses – Corroboration by seizure of weapon and ammunition – Sentence review – whether excessive.
|
18 January 1988 |
|
Conviction for theft of cooperative society public store upheld; sentence increased from five to eight years imprisonment.
Criminal law – stealing by a public servant – custody and control of public store proved by possession of keys and store records – defence of having handed over custody rejected. Sentencing – adequacy of sentence for theft of public property – appellate enhancement from five to eight years for deterrence and protection of public interest.
|
16 January 1988 |
|
Appellant failed to prove ownership of disputed shamba; appeal dismissed for lack of credible supporting evidence.
Land dispute — ownership of cultivated land (shamba); burden of proof on claimant; credibility and independence of witnesses; inadmissibility/limited weight of hearsay; appellate review of factual findings.
|
11 January 1988 |
Civil Practice and Procedure - Jurisdiction - Rent Restriction Area - S. 126 (h) of the Rent Restriction Act, 1985. |
11 January 1988 |
|
The applicants' appeals against burglary and theft convictions dismissed where confessions and possession of stolen property were proved.
Criminal law – Burglary and theft – Conviction supported by confessions and recovery of recently stolen property – Possession by co-accused established despite mutual blame-shifting; sentences upheld as appropriate.
|
11 January 1988 |
|
|
8 January 1988 |
|
Convictions quashed where identification was unreliable and the appellants' alibi was not considered.
Criminal law – Identification evidence – reliability affected by poor lighting, torch shone into complainant’s face, and fright – need for caution in convicting on such evidence alone. Criminal procedure – Defence of alibi – trial court’s failure to assess alibi when identification is weak can vitiate conviction. Evidence – absence of recovered stolen property and lack of independent corroboration undermines prosecution case; burden to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt not met.
|
8 January 1988 |
Criminal Practice and Procedure - Bail - Surety for accused person - Accused travels to Dar es Salaam to look for an advocate - Fails to appear due to lack of transport - Surety ordered to pay expenses incurred by the witnesses and forfeit bond - Whether proper |
7 January 1988 |
|
Unauthorised use of entrusted village funds is theft despite later repayment; conviction and three-year sentence upheld.
Criminal law – theft – misapplication of funds entrusted for a specific purpose – unauthorized use constitutes theft despite later repayment; sentence upheld as proper.
|
7 January 1988 |
|
A non‑refundable brideprice clause is void and payment is recoverable when the promised marriage does not occur.
Contract law – agreements relating to marriage – brideprice – enforceability of non‑refund clauses – Section 28, Law of Contract Ordinance 1961 – lack of consideration and restitution.
|
6 January 1988 |
|
Convictions quashed where defective charge sheet and denial of counsel rendered the trial unfair; release ordered due to time served.
Criminal procedure — defective charge sheet and improperly joined particulars — right to counsel and fair trial — remedial discretion between retrial and quashing where appellants have largely served sentence.
|
6 January 1988 |
|
Applicant's conviction quashed where alibi was unrebutted and identification parade was improper, creating reasonable doubt.
Theft — sufficiency of identification evidence; alibi — requirement for prosecution to rebut; identification parade — necessity and propriety; contradictions in prosecution account; possession of ammunition by game personnel — lawful possession issue; appellate intervention where conviction unsafe.
|
2 January 1988 |
|
Persistent adultery, eviction and a pronounced 'talak' supported finding that the marriage had irretrievably broken down.
Family law – divorce – irretrievable breakdown of marriage – adultery, cruelty, eviction and pronouncement of 'talak' as evidence of breakdown; appellate review of trial magistrate's factual findings.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Appeal against conviction for stealing by servant dismissed; appellate court upheld trial court’s credibility findings and three-year sentence.
Criminal law – Theft by servant (ss. 271, 265 Penal Code) – Identification of stolen property – Credibility findings of trial court – Appellate deference to magistrate who saw and heard witnesses.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Complaint against advocate for failing to prosecute appeal and refund fees dismissed; delay due to missing court record and expenses accepted.
Professional conduct of advocates – alleged failure to prosecute appeal – whether delay attributable to advocate or missing court records – evidence from court clerks and magistrate. Payment characterization – fee versus advance for expenses – burden of proof and credibility findings. Relief – claim for refund refused where expenses plausibly exceed amount received.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Traditional village 'army' unlawfully assumed judicial power, extorted payment and assaulted the plaintiff; defendants held liable and damages awarded.
Traditional/local dispute resolution – limits of authority – unlawful assumption of judicial powers by village traditional armies; Penal Code s.99 – Guidelines for Traditional Armies incompatible with Constitution; civil liability for extortion, trespass and assault; awards of restitution, special and general damages.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Appeal dismissed: conviction for theft by a public servant upheld and mandatory five-year sentence affirmed as required by law.
Criminal law – Theft by person employed in public service – Penal Code ss.25 and 270 – sufficiency of evidence to convict. Sentencing – statutory mandatory minimum sentence – value threshold exceeding Shs.5,000 requires five years' imprisonment. Appeals – frivolous/groundless appeals – summary rejection and certification of lack of sufficient grounds.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
A court must rely only on evidence adduced in court; unsworn letters from officials are inadmissible without the author testifying.
Evidence — admissibility of unsworn letters from local officials; attachment/objection proceedings — courts must rely on evidence adduced in court; witnesses must be called and be subject to cross‑examination; appellate confirmation of substantive finding despite procedural irregularity.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Conviction quashed where recovered empty bottles were not reliably identified and recent-possession inference was inapplicable.
Criminal law – Theft and shopbreaking – Identification of recovered property – Necessity of proof of special marks or reliable identification before invoking recent possession; Evidence Act s.127(2) – Competency of child witness – requirements for receiving evidence of a child.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
A party must first seek to set aside an ex parte injunction under Order XXXVII r.4 before appealing to a higher court.
Civil procedure — Ex parte injunctions — Requirement to apply to trial court to set aside ex parte orders under Order XXXVII r.4 before appealing under Order XL r.1(2); exhaustion of remedies; requirements for granting injunctive relief (adequate affidavit, notice, demonstration of irreparable harm).
|
1 January 1988 |
|
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Whether cohabitation amounted to marriage and whether a person with a subsisting marriage can obtain separation or divorce.
Family law – Cohabitation versus marriage; validity of subsequent marriage where a subsisting monogamous marriage exists; competence to grant divorce or separation; division of matrimonial assets and finality where no appeal is taken.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Acquittal for causing death by dangerous driving affirmed because prosecution failed to prove dangerous driving or make a prima facie case.
Road traffic — Dangerous driving — Burden to make out prima facie case at close of prosecution — Sudden swerve into oncoming traffic ordinarily requires an explanation — Absence of explanation may permit inference of negligence, but conviction cannot rest on speculation; acquittal upheld where evidence insufficient.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Removal of timber before measurement and marking violates the Forests Ordinance; licence alone does not legalise possession.
Forests Ordinance – section 22A(b)(ii) – removal of timber before measurement and marking – constitutes offence even if licensee authorised to fell trees. Licence does not alone legalise possession of timber; compliance with measurement/marking condition is prerequisite. Sentencing powers – section 26(1) – forfeiture of unlawfully obtained forest produce and cancellation of licences permissible. Sentencing limitation – disqualification from holding licences must be for a specified period, not indefinite.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Reported
Possession dispute is governed by the Rent Restriction Act; Regional Housing Tribunal, not Resident Magistrate, has jurisdiction.
Rent Restriction Act 1985 – jurisdiction – Regional Housing Tribunal’s power under s.12(1)(h) to order recovery of possession – distinction between trespass and tenancy/sub‑tenancy (ss.36–37) – Magistrates’ Court Act s.44(b) remedy to quash and transfer proceedings.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Appeal dismissed for failure to attach mandatory copy of decree to memorandum of appeal; not curable under section 95.
Civil procedure – Appeal procedure – Order 39 Rule 1 – Memorandum of appeal must be accompanied by a copy of the decree appealed from – requirement mandatory. Civil procedure – Section 95 – Amendment/clerical error – not available to cure omission of mandatory accompanying document. Appeal dismissed for incompetence; costs awarded to respondent.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
A substituted or amended criminal charge that adds an accused requires pleading and opportunity to recall witnesses; evidence from a withdrawn charge cannot support a new charge.
Criminal procedure – Amendment or substitution of charge under s234(1) – Accused must plead to amended charge and be given opportunity to recall witnesses or adduce fresh evidence; Withdrawal of charge under s98 – evidence adduced under withdrawn charge cannot support subsequent substituted charge; Magistrate’s premature closure of prosecution case – usurpation of prosecution function and procedural unfairness.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Reported
Adoption granted to sole male guardian of a female infant due to special circumstances and the child's best interests.
Adoption — special circumstances disapplying statutory prohibition on sole male adopter of female child; statutory requirements (age, parental consent, custody, child's assent); best interests of the child; conditional bond.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Appeal dismissed where appellant knowingly cohabited with and married a woman still legally married to the respondent, constituting adultery.
Family/customary marriage – existence of legal marriage and absence of divorce – effect on subsequent association; Adultery – liability for compensation where a person knowingly cohabits with another’s legally married spouse; Appeal – appellate court affirmation of lower courts’ factual findings and award of damages.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Appellate court upheld convictions but adjusted the disorderly conduct sentence to the correct statutory penalty (fine or short imprisonment).
Criminal law – Evidence – credibility of police and medical evidence corroborating assault by biting; Criminal law – Offences – disorderly conduct under Police Force Ordinance and assault occasioning actual bodily harm; Sentencing – statutory penalty for offence under Police Force Ordinance and appellate adjustment of sentence; Appellate review – when court will not interfere with trial court's sentencing discretion.
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Taxation of a Bill of Costs was reduced for lack of receipts and to give effect to Court of Appeal orders, leaving shs. 297,325/= allowed.
Civil procedure – taxation of costs – necessity of vouchers/receipts to prove travel, accommodation and subsistence expenses Taxation – GN 515 of 1991 (Rules 51 and 57) – taxing officer’s discretion to allow reasonable expenses and disallow unsupported items Costs – effect of appellate orders on taxation (reduction of proportion payable and ordered refunds) Procedure – recourse under Rule 5 GN 515 of 1991 to refer disputed taxation to a Judge
|
1 January 1988 |
|
Long continuous occupation (17 years) of customary land can give ownership by adverse possession; appeal dismissed with costs.
Land law – Customary tenure – Ownership depends on use – Adverse possession – Prolonged occupation (17 years) enables acquisition of ownership where original owner abandoned land – Land Ordinance (Cap 113).
|
1 January 1988 |