Results.
433 judgments found.
Citation
Sort by Citation ascending
Judgment date
Sort by Judgment date ascending
August 2025
The court granted a time extension for appeal due to technical delays, deeming them excusable under 'good cause'.
Civil procedure — extension of time — Good cause for delay — Procedural Technicalities — Diligence in Appeal Processes
6 August 2025
Appellant's rape conviction upheld due to sufficient evidence despite alleged procedural and evidential discrepancies.
Criminal law — Rape — Statutory rape and evaluation of evidence — Sufficiency and credibility of evidence — Procedural delay in arraignment
5 August 2025
The conviction was overturned due to inadmissible child testimony and procedural irregularities in trial proceedings.
Criminal law — Admissibility of evidence — Child witness testimony — Procedural irregularity in magistrate change — Fair trial
1 August 2025
July 2025
The appellant failed to prove existence and terms of an oral contract; appeal dismissed with costs to respondent.
Contract law — oral contracts — Evidence required to prove existence and enforceability of oral agreements — Balance of probabilities in civil proceedings
31 July 2025
Primary Court had jurisdiction over cattle theft; claims of lack of jurisdiction, gravity-based transfer, and bias were rejected.
Criminal law — Jurisdiction of primary courts — unlawful sentence beyond Primary Court limits — Minimum Sentences Act proviso
Criminal procedure — recusal and transfer — Allegations of bias, interlocutory recusal rulings not amenable to transfer application while main case pending
31 July 2025
Application dismissed for lack of a valid supporting affidavit due to missing date and identification details.
Civil procedure — Affidavits — Validity issues due to missing date and deponent identification as per statutory requirements
30 July 2025
Court grants divorce due to irreparable marriage breakdown and divides property per parties' agreement.
Family law — Matrimonial law — Divorce — Irreparable breakdown of marriage — Division of matrimonial property
29 July 2025
Failure to retry an original case as ordered by the High Court results in nullification of subsequent proceedings.
Civil procedure — Appeal — Procedural Irregularity — Compliance with Court Orders — Nullity of Proceedings
28 July 2025
Conviction for forgery and theft quashed due to insufficient material evidence and unreliability of witnesses.
Criminal law — Forgery — Stealing by Servant — Burden of proof — Material evidence and witness discrepancies
25 July 2025
Appeal dismissed as appellant failed to meet fraud proof standards in civil litigation; electronic evidence inadmissible.
Civil procedure — Appeal — evidential standards for proving fraud in civil cases — admissibility of electronic evidence in primary courts
25 July 2025
Court quashes statutory rape conviction due to unproved victim age and improperly considered defense.
Criminal law — Statutory rape — proof of age and penetration — Evaluation of Evidence and Defense in Sexual Offences
23 July 2025
Appeal allowed where penetration was not proved and the trial court failed to properly evaluate defence evidence.
Criminal law — sexual offences against a child — Rape — proof required and role of medical evidence
Appellate practice — first appellate court conducts rehearing and may make fresh findings — First appellate court’s duty to objectively re-assess both prosecution and defence evidence
Evidence — Medical evidence in sexual offences — confirms penetration but need not identify the assailant
23 July 2025
Applicant failed to prove timely e-filing or account for delay; no good cause shown, extension denied.
Civil procedure — Electronic filing — Duty to file electronically and to follow up electronic dockets — Judicature and Application of Laws (Electronic Filing) Rules, 2018 (Rules 8, 9, 24(5))
Criminal procedure — Extension of time to appeal — Requirements to account for each day of delay — Criminal Procedure Act ss. 378 — 379
22 July 2025
Trial court judgment is invalidated due to lack of recorded sentence and procedural errors, remand for rewritten judgment.
Criminal law — invalid judgment — lack of proper sentencing process — appeal due to unrecorded sentence and procedural errors in trial court judgment
22 July 2025
The trial court erred in expunging admitted exhibits, making the judgment null and ordering a fresh judgment.
Civil procedure — expungement of exhibits — functus officio — right to be heard — evaluation of evidence
17 July 2025
Court upheld breach of contract finding, adjusted general damages due to lack of evidence support but dismissed the appeal.
Contract law — Frustration — Breach of contract — Award of general damages — Admittance of debt in contract disputes
15 July 2025
DLHT lacked jurisdiction over land title dispute; authority rests with High Court and Registrar of Titles.
Land law — Jurisdiction — District Land and Housing Tribunal — Authority over registered land and certificates of title — Necessary party involvement
14 July 2025
Court quashes housebreaking conviction but upholds theft conviction; plea defects invalidated one charge.
Criminal law — Plea of guilty — Ambiguity in charges affecting plea validity
14 July 2025
Court orders trial de novo after DLHT misapplies limitation period for refiling land disputes.
Land law — Limitation period — refiled application after being struck out — errors in DLHT decision
14 July 2025
Tribunal's decision nullified due to lack of proper jurisdiction arising from procedural defects.
Land law — Jurisdiction and mediation requirements in tenancy disputes — Admissibility of evidence in tribunal proceedings
11 July 2025
Procedural non-compliance in appointing an estate administrator rendered the process invalid due to lack of proper public notice.
Probate law — Appointment of estate administrator — Procedural fairness — Jurisdiction of courts in estate matters
11 July 2025
Appellate court upheld rape conviction of a seven‑year‑old based on credible victim, eyewitness and medical evidence.
Criminal law — sexual offences — Rape: proof of penetration and age — Proof of elements: age, penetration and identity
Evidence — Evaluation of witness credibility — Evaluation of victim and eyewitness testimony — Corroboration by medical report (PF3) and flagrante delicto recovery
11 July 2025
The DLHT for Geita failed to ascertain its jurisdiction due to contradictory location claims, warranting a re-trial.
Land law — Jurisdiction — Jurisdictional errors due to unverified geographical territory
10 July 2025
The appellant's conviction was overturned due to unreliable evidence and identification.
Criminal law — Unnatural offence — Burden of proof
10 July 2025
The appeal against the rape conviction was granted due to insufficient evidence and material inconsistencies.
Criminal law — Rape — Burden of proof — Credibility of victim's testimony — Inconsistencies creating reasonable doubt
10 July 2025
Conviction quashed where identification, recent possession and uncorroborated confessions failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.
Criminal law
— doctrine of recent possession — elements required: possession, positive proof of ownership, recentness and relation to charge
— Visual identification — requirements and reliability (Waziri Amani)
Criminal procedure — cautioned statements — Admissibility and weight of confession corroborating other evidence
10 July 2025
Temporary injunction in a bank account dispute found appropriate and not prejudicial to the main case.
Civil procedure — Temporary injunctions — Effect on the main case — Relevance of bank account names — Requirement of demonstrating irreparable harm
8 July 2025
An illegal property auction due to procedural errors and unclear collateral agreements leads to restoring property to original owner.
Land law — collateral security — auction procedures — injunction against unauthorized property sale — procedural compliance in joiner of parties
4 July 2025
Application for extension of time to appeal dismissed due to lack of sufficient cause and unaccounted delay.
Civil procedure — extension of time — Sufficient cause for delay — evidentiary requirements for accounting delay
4 July 2025
Appeal struck out for being time-barred beyond the statutory limit without a valid request for judgment documents exclusion.
Land law — ownership dispute — Time-barred appeal — Exclusion of time
4 July 2025
Conviction quashed for trial irregularities and evidential insufficiency, appellants to be released.
Criminal law — Assault occasioning bodily harm — evidential discrepancies — procedural irregularity in magistrate reassignment — conviction quashed
2 July 2025
The court found insufficient evidence to convict the accused of murder due to flawed DNA evidence and unreliable witness identification.
Criminal law — Murder — Admissibility of DNA evidence — Duty to prove beyond reasonable doubt
2 July 2025
Subordinate court lacked EOCCA jurisdiction; conviction quashed and retrial refused due to cumulative procedural defects.
Criminal law — Jurisdiction of subordinate courts under EOCCA — Validity of certificate required to confer jurisdiction — EOCCA ss 12(3), 26
Criminal procedure — reassignment of partly heard trial — failure renders successor’s proceedings and resultant convictions null — Criminal Procedure Act s 214 (now s 230)
Evidence — Expert identification and valuation — Identification and valuation of wildlife trophies — Need for distinguishing features and proper valuation documentation — Wildlife Conservation (Valuation of Trophy) Regulations (GN No. 207 of 2012)
2 July 2025
June 2025
Land appeal dismissed due to statute of limitations and proper hearing procedures observed.
Land law — Appeal against tribunal decision — Suit dismissed as time-barred — Right to be heard properly observed
27 June 2025
Appellant failed to discharge the burden of proof; tribunal properly accepted respondents' oral village-allocation evidence and dismissed appeal.
Civil procedure
— Burden of proof in civil cases
— Civil procedure code order XXVI — commissioning of witness testimony is discretionary and requires supporting material or application
Evidence
— Failure to call material witnesses — adverse inference where witness within reach and no justification provided
— oral testimony of village leaders/village chairperson admissible and may suffice under Law of Evidence for allocations
Land law — village land allocation evidence and long possession/development relevant to possession rights
20 June 2025
Conviction quashed where prosecution relied on hearsay, uncorroborated co‑accused confession, and vague charge lacking particulars.
Criminal law — Theft — Whether prosecution proved theft beyond reasonable doubt — identification evidence
Criminal procedure — Appeal — Failure by first appellate court to address all grounds of appeal — Second appellate court stepping into appellate shoes
Evidence — Hearsay — Hearsay statements by co-accused insufficient to sustain conviction — Requirement for corroboration and formal certification under Rules of Evidence
20 June 2025
Failure to show timely request and proof of receipt for CMA proceedings is not good cause for extension to seek revision.
Labour law — Extension of time to file revision — good cause
— diligence and accounting for each day of delay
— Notice of intention (CMA Form 10) is not a request for certified proceedings
16 June 2025
Denial of legal representation and failure to consider affidavit vitiated tribunal proceedings, warranting rehearing.
Civil procedure — submissions are not evidence
Constitutional law — right to be heard (Article 13(6)(a)) — Right to legal representation and audi alteram partem
Land disputes — Setting aside ex‑parte judgment
— Regulation 11(2)
— Setting aside ex parte proceedings and remitting for rehearing
13 June 2025
Second appeal dismissed: new maintenance claim inadmissible; presumed marriage not a formal marriage for s.107 divorce.
Family law
— Appellate procedure — inadmissibility of fresh grounds first raised on appeal
— Division of matrimonial property — previously adjudicated improvements not re-distributable
— Maintenance — assessment, judicial notice of employment and variation of quantum
— presumed marriage
— Res judicata — new cause of action where parties reconcile and create new facts
10 June 2025
High Court quashed CMA’s rectification of a quashed award, finding the change from 875 to 865 substantive, not clerical.
Civil procedure
— Interlocutory versus final orders
— revisional jurisdiction — High Court power to examine CMA rulings that are substantive or effectively final
Jurisdiction
— correction of an award quashed by a superior court
— functus officio doctrine
Labour law — rectification of arbitral awards
10 June 2025
An affidavit containing untrue statements vitiates the application and warrants striking it out with costs.
Civil procedure
— Affidavits — confined to facts within deponent’s knowledge
— Affidavits tainted with falsehoods — render affidavit incompetent and justify striking out application
— Hearsay — statements attributed to others require supporting affidavit
— Preliminary objections — determination before merits
10 June 2025
Appeal dismissed: conviction upheld on recent possession, circumstantial evidence and procedurally defective alibi.
Criminal law — housebreaking and stealing — doctrine of recent possession — Sufficiency and reliability of evidence
Criminal procedure — Variance between charge particulars and evidence — Amendment under s234 CPA — Alibi disclosure requirements under s194(4) — (5) CPA
Evidence — Identification of stolen property — sufficiency of proof by complainant’s identification and markings — Chain of custody/seizure procedures
9 June 2025
Eyewitness and medical evidence upheld grievous‑harm conviction despite minor inconsistencies and alleged unlawful detention.
Criminal law — Grievous harm — sufficiency and credibility of eyewitness and medical evidence
Criminal procedure — defence of alibi (s.194(4) CPA) — Requirement to notify alibi (s194(4)-(5) CPA) and prejudice required to vitiate conviction (s32 CPA)
Evidence — Credibility and contradictions — Minor inconsistencies do not necessarily vitiate a conviction
6 June 2025
Prisoner’s unproven claim of timely filing and unaccounted delay did not justify extension of time to appeal.
Criminal procedure — Extension of time to file appeal under section 361(2) CPA — Lyamuya factors applied — Inordinate delay and lack of documentary proof fatal — Allegations involving third parties require corroborating affidavits to avoid hearsay
3 June 2025
May 2025
A tribunal must first determine a claimant’s citizenship and legal capacity before adjudicating land ownership under the Land Act.
Civil procedure
— Appeals
— compliance is determinative of competency
— factual disputes cannot be disposed of as preliminary points
— Preliminary objections
— revisional jurisdiction — High Court may set aside tribunal proceedings where jurisdictional or material irregularities affect adjudication
Land law — non‑citizen ownership
30 May 2025
Accused convicted of manslaughter after reliable eyewitness identification and medical evidence; sentenced to five years imprisonment.
Criminal law — Manslaughter — proof beyond reasonable doubt
Criminal law — Visual identification
— adequacy of lighting, proximity, prompt description and police report
— alibi requirements
— causation via post‑mortem blunt force trauma
— sentencing discretion
30 May 2025
Leave for judicial review refused because applicants failed to exhaust prescribed cooperative dispute remedies.
Administrative law — Judicial review — Leave to apply for prerogative writs — prerequisites: sufficient interest, arguable case, decision, exhaustion of local remedies, six-month limitation
Commercial law — Cooperative law — Dispute resolution
— Minister’s decision final
— Regulation 83: referral to Registrar and appeal to Minister
29 May 2025
Court granted extension to file appeal papers after accepting e-filing reference and custodial/logistical explanations as sufficient cause.
Civil procedure
— Electronic filing (e-cms) — court may take judicial notice of e-CMS reference numbers stated in sworn affidavits
— Requirement to account for delay
Criminal procedure — extension of time to file notice of intention and petition of appeal — sufficient cause required
Tort — Procedural lapse vs. negligence — custodial status and logistical constraints may justify delay
27 May 2025
Variance in charge particulars and failure to call material witnesses rendered the appellant's charges unproven.
Criminal law
— Charge particulars — Variance between charged place and evidence
— Personation — identity disputes and sufficiency of evidence to prove personation
Telecommunications law
— adverse inference if not called
— SIM card registration
27 May 2025
Conviction quashed for unreliable visual identification, defective recent possession evidence, and inadmissible statements.
Criminal law — Armed robbery — Elements required to prove armed robbery
Evidence
— Admissibility of written statements under s.34B Evidence Act — Admission and notice under s.34B — Cautioned statements — Compliance with s.57 Criminal Procedure Act
— Visual identification — Conditions favouring correct identification (lighting, distance, observation time)
27 May 2025