Results.
433 judgments found.
Citation
Sort by Citation ascending
Judgment date
Sort by Judgment date ascending
May 2025
Conviction quashed where victim's age and identification were unproven and judgment contained extraneous, prejudicial facts.
Criminal law — preliminary answers not evidence — Documentary discrepancy affecting proof
Criminal law — Sexual offence evidence
— burden of proof never shifts from prosecution
— unexplained delay in reporting
Criminal law — Statutory rape — Proof of age required
22 May 2025
Acquittal where prosecution failed to prove causation and credible medical or eyewitness evidence in a manslaughter charge.
Criminal law — Manslaughter — elements: death, unlawful act causing death, absence of malice aforethought — Requirement that medical and eyewitness evidence establish causation beyond reasonable doubt
Criminal procedure — Investigation — Failure to secure scene, recover weapons or provide sketch map undermines identification and prosecution case
Evidence — Expert medical evidence — Limits of post‑mortem evidence where dissection/internal findings are absent — Court may decline to rely on speculative expert conclusions
19 May 2025
Appeal allowed: conviction unsafe due to unreliable identification and uncorroborated confessions.
Criminal law — Armed robbery — visual identification
Criminal law — Identification parade
— confirmatory only
— post-offence procedural witnesses are not eyewitnesses to identity. Cautioned and extra-judicial statements implicating co-accused require independent corroboration
— uncorroborated confessions insufficient to sustain conviction
16 May 2025
Appellants’ conviction for cattle theft upheld: direct, corroborated identification and evidence proved theft beyond reasonable doubt.
Criminal law — Cattle theft
— admissibility and role of documentary proof and judicial notice
— appellate re-evaluation of evidence
— direct versus circumstantial evidence
— elements of stealing (possession, movement, intent, dishonesty, lack of consent)
— proof beyond reasonable doubt
14 May 2025
Annexures to affidavits in chamber summons are evidence and need not be formally tendered as exhibits.
Civil procedure
— Chamber applications — Affidavit as primary evidence — Admissibility of documents annexed to affidavits
— Admissibility of exhibits — Applicability of Exhibit Management Guidelines/Order XIII to affidavit‑based applications
Natural justice — Right to be heard — Expunging unchallenged annexures deprived applicant of evidential basis and occasioned miscarriage of justice
13 May 2025
Appeal dismissed: DLHT properly rejected execution claim where High Court had not ordered payment and parties were heard.
Civil procedure — Execution proceedings — requirement of an underlying court order for specific monetary execution
Civil procedure — Procedure — Preliminary objection
— court not required to determine non-existent preliminary objection first
— no objection filed
Constitutional law — right to be heard (Article 13(6)(a))
— no surprise hearing
— parties were afforded opportunity to address court
13 May 2025
Unexplained 26-day delay, unsupported bereavement and weak medical evidence do not justify extension of time.
Civil procedure — extension of time
— Application under Civil Procedure (Appeals in Proceedings Originating in Primary Court) Rules
— bereavement and sickness
13 May 2025
Court held the disputed Shilabela house was a matrimonial asset acquired during the relationship and dismissed the appeal.
Family law — Matrimonial property
— contradictions undermine credibility
— division
— oral evidence admissible
— proof on balance of probabilities
12 May 2025
The applicant’s unchallenged domestic and farming contributions entitled her to 40% of the disputed matrimonial house; appeal allowed.
Civil procedure — Appeal — appellate court erred by ignoring unchallenged evidence of contribution and depriving spouse of any share
Evidence — proof of joint efforts — domestic chores and farming constitute non-monetary contributions
Family law — Matrimonial property — division of assets acquired during cohabitation under presumption of marriage — jurisdiction
12 May 2025
An appeal is timely if the applicant electronically files on the thirtieth day, computed from the day after the judgment.
Civil procedure
— Appeals from Primary Court to District Court — time limitation — Computation excludes date of delivery; 30-day period runs from the day after judgment (Magistrates' Courts Act s 20(3); Interpretation of Laws Act s 60(1)(b))
— Electronic filing — filing date is date of submission through e‑filing system — Electronic submission before midnight counts as filing (Judicature and Application of Laws (Electronic Filing) Rules, 2018 r 21(1))
9 May 2025
Extension of time granted where prisoner timely filed notice in trial court but procedural transmission failure prevented High Court filing.
Criminal procedure — Notice of intention to appeal filed by prisoner — delay caused by prison authorities treated as not attributable to prisoner
Criminal procedure — extension of time to file notice of appeal and appeal
— Law of Limitation Act s 14(1)
— Whether sufficient cause shown
9 May 2025
Sentences quashed where trial court misapplied discretionary sentencing; fines preferred for first offenders absent aggravation.
Appellate practice — Appellate interference — manifestly excessive sentence, wrong principle, failure to consider mitigation
Criminal law
— Sentencing discretion — alternative fine discretionary
— Sentencing factors — mitigation (first offender, remorse, age, dependants, nature of weapon, plea) versus aggravation (cruelty/leaving intoxicated victim)
8 May 2025
Appeal struck out for failure to transmit the Primary Court record, leaving the High Court without jurisdiction to decide merits.
Appellate practice
— Appeal procedure — mandatory transmission of Primary Court record — non-compliance renders appeal incompetent
— consent judgement — generally not appealable absent vitiating factors
— jurisdiction — cannot be exercised without trial record
7 May 2025
Appellants succeed: respondent failed to prove a concluded auction and non‑joinder of purchaser was fatal; appeal allowed.
Land law
— Auction procedures — requirement of 60‑day notice, 14‑day public notice and licensed auctioneer
— Locus and privity — borrower’s limits where third‑party mortgage exists
— mortgagee’s power of sale
— Proof of public auction — Certificate of Sale as primary proof
— tribunal jurisdiction — cannot alter loan terms absent agreement
7 May 2025
Cautioned statements procured without statutory safeguards and an uncorroborated co‑accused confession cannot sustain a conviction.
Criminal law
— alibi evidence — Alibi defence — Requirement of prior notice and need for corroboration under section 194 CPA
— confession of co-accused — conviction cannot be based solely on co-accused's confession — Evidence Act s 33
— Evidence — Admissibility of cautioned statements — Section 57(2)(e) Cap 20 R.E. 2002
7 May 2025
Appellant failed to prove matrimonial assets and was bound by trial evidence; maintenance increased to TSh 300,000.
Family law — Maintenance — enhancement of maintenance
Family law — Matrimonial property — division
— burden to prove existence and joint efforts
— inadmissibility of new evidence on appeal
— parties bound by their trial evidence
6 May 2025
A revisional court that raises issues suo motu must afford parties a hearing; failure to do so vitiates its decision.
Civil procedure — revisional jurisdiction — nullification of defective proceedings and ordering of retrial
Constitutional law — right to be heard (Article 13(6)(a)) — suo motu determinations affecting rights without hearing render proceedings a nullity — Article 13(6)(a)
5 May 2025
Wrong citation of law renders an application incompetent and should be struck out, not dismissed.
Civil procedure
— Competence of application — Wrong citation of enabling provision renders application incompetent — Incompetence attracts striking out, not dismissal
— Restoration of dismissed application — Proper provision and curable procedural defects — Striking out preserves right to refile
5 May 2025
Retrenchment agreement and acceptance of payment estop employee from challenging retrenchment or claiming remaining fixed‑term salary.
Labour law
— estoppel after acceptance of retrenchment package
— FILO/LIFO as consultative selection criteria
— no mandatory production of bank financial statements for operational retrenchment
— procedural adjournments caused by party
— retrenchment agreement binding
— unpleaded duress cannot be raised on rejoinder
2 May 2025
Appeal struck out for wrong mode of appeal and missing decree; mandatory procedural rules prevail over overriding objective.
Civil procedure — Appeals from subordinate courts
2 May 2025
April 2025
Post‑separation agreements and minor‑named transfers cannot oust matrimonial assets from division if induced by undue pressure or legally ineffective.
Family law
— Capacity to contract — minors cannot validly purchase land
— Division of matrimonial property — scope of section 114(1) LMA — disposals to children and effect on matrimonial estate
— Evidence — probative value of documentary evidence and adverse inference for failure to call material witnesses
— Validity of post‑separation agreements — undue pressure, fair‑sharing and vitiating factors
30 April 2025
Technical delay excused; brief post-decision delay reasonably explained—extension to appeal granted with filing timelines.
Criminal procedure — extension of time to file notice of intention to appeal and appeal out of time — technical delay excusable where applicant diligently pursues remedies — Lyamuya factors — reasonableness of short post-decision delay (prison transfers and obtaining certified documents)
29 April 2025
Limitation runs from receipt of judgment; court granted 14-day extension after applicant filed extension application within time.
Civil procedure — extension of time — Computation of limitation
29 April 2025
Sole breadwinner status alone does not establish exceptional circumstances for bail pending appeal after conviction.
Criminal procedure
— Bail pending appeal — Onus on applicant to show overwhelming prospects of success or exceptional circumstances — Criminal Procedure Act s 368
— Interests of justice — Seriousness of offence and maintenance of public confidence may outweigh personal liberty
— requires exceptional and unusual reasons — Sole breadwinner status insufficient without corroborative evidence of irreparable hardship
28 April 2025
An executing court must investigate a pending Order 21 objection before ordering sale; a sale during objection is void.
Civil procedure — Execution — judicial function
25 April 2025
Appeal dismissed: confessions and leading police to recovered firearm sufficed to prove unlawful possession.
Criminal law — Possession of firearms — proof of ownership/possession — Admissibility of confessions and discovery under Evidence Act s 31
Evidence
— hearsay and witness credibility — Firsthand recovery testimony is direct evidence, not hearsay
— Photographic/video evidence — Absence of photographic/video evidence not fatal where credible oral testimony and seizure documentation exist
24 April 2025
Extension dismissed because time of the struck‑out revision was excluded under the Law of Limitation Act.
Labour law — Revision of CMA award — Time runs from service of the award under s.91(1)(a) ELRA
Limitation law — section 21(2) exclusion — Law of Limitation Act s 21(2) is for exclusion/computation of time, not an enabling provision
14 April 2025
Extension granted to file appeal due to arguable illegality despite applicant’s unexplained long delay.
Civil procedure
— Enforcement — Execution pending — prejudice considerations against granting extension
— extension of time — negligence of counsel
— limitation — extension of time — good cause factors (Lyamuya) — duty to account for each day of delay
Evidence — Evidence/procedure — Alleged expungement of exhibits at judgment stage and functus officio — illegality apparent on record as standalone ground for extension
14 April 2025
An appellate court that decides a suo motu issue without placing it on record and hearing parties violates the right to be heard.
Administrative and Constitutional Law Right to be heard (audi alteram partem) Requirement to place suo motu issues on record and afford parties hearing; failure vitiates proceedings. Civil Procedure Appellate jurisdiction Limits on raising and deciding issues not pleaded in grounds of appeal. Matrimonial Law Requirement of marriage conciliation board certificate (s.101, Law of Marriage Act) procedural fairness in contesting compliance
14 April 2025
Applicant’s extension of time for revision refused: delay unaccounted and alleged illegality not apparent on the record.
Limitation law — Land Disputes Courts Act — requirement of assessors
Limitation law — Limitation of actions — Extension of time — good cause
— Lyamuya criteria
— revision against tribunal judgment
8 April 2025
A contractual clause requiring negotiation then arbitration must be exhausted before court proceedings; suit struck out with costs.
Arbitration — Arbitration clause
— contractual interpretation
— enforceability of arbitration clauses
— premature filing
— waiver/estoppel of right to arbitrate
— sequential dispute-resolution (negotiation, arbitration, litigation)
— stay
8 April 2025
Restoration application dismissed as time‑barred because filing date is date of fee payment/control number, not electronic upload.
Limitation law
— Electronic filing — date of filing — issuance of control number/payment of fees
— jurisdiction — time‑bar renders application incompetent
— restoration of proceedings dismissed for want of prosecution
8 April 2025
Application for attachment before judgment dismissed for lack of the underlying contract, translation, and supporting evidence.
Civil procedure — Attachment before judgment — requirements: prima facie case — Risk of asset dissipation evidential burden — Order XXXVI r.6, Civil Procedure Code
8 April 2025
Summary judgment awarded for recovery of unpaid NSSF contributions after defendant failed to seek leave to defend.
Civil procedure — Order XXXV summary procedure — leave to defend — where defendants fail to obtain leave, plaint allegations deemed admitted
Employment law — Employer’s duty to remit statutory social security contributions — Recovery of unpaid contributions and statutory penalties — National Social Security Fund Act
8 April 2025
Appellants’ kidnapping convictions upheld despite inadmissible confessions; corroborated evidence proved guilt.
Criminal law — Kidnapping
— admissibility of cautioned and extrajudicial statements
— appellate duty to reassess defence where trial court fails to evaluate it
— sufficiency of corroborated direct evidence
4 April 2025
Appeal dismissed: dispute was res judicata after prior probate decision, and parties were heard on the preliminary objection.
Land law — Res judicata — prior probate decision excluding land from deceased's estate
— DLHT precluded from rehearing
— jurisdictional challenge via appeal required
— orders distinguished from judgments
— parties afforded right to be heard on preliminary objection
3 April 2025
Summary judgment granted to applicants for unpaid statutory pension contributions after respondent failed to appear.
Summary judgment; Order XXXV Civil Procedure Code; section 74A(1) NSSF Act; substituted and published service; default judgment; unpaid statutory pension contributions and penalties; interest and costs.
3 April 2025
Appellant failed to prove ownership; invalid sale by heirs did not confer title—appeal dismissed with costs.
Land law
— Evidence — burden to prove ownership and identity of auctioned land
— Remedies — invalid sale leaves land as unadministered estate, not transferred to appellant
— sale by heirs without letters of administration — nemo dat quod non habet — sale may be invalid but does not confer title on third parties lacking proof of ownership
2 April 2025
Absence of DPP consent and certificate vitiated trial of an economic offence; conviction quashed and retrial ordered.
Civil procedure — Procedure — Jurisdictional defects may be raised suo motu at appellate stage provided parties are given notice and opportunity to be heard
Civil procedure — remedy
— Quash proceedings, set aside conviction and sentence, order retrial before a different magistrate
— sentence to account for time served
Criminal law — Economic offences — jurisdiction
2 April 2025
Conviction overturned because seizure receipt was not a lawful, signed certificate and possession was not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Criminal law — Possession of suspected stolen property — Search and seizure formalities — recent possession doctrine
2 April 2025
Attachment of judgment‑debtor property valid despite bank encumbrance; third party must object; revision dismissed with costs.
Civil procedure — Execution — Attachment of judgment-debtor's property — Third‑party encumbrance does not automatically defeat attachment
2 April 2025
Applicant failed to show good cause for extension of time to lodge appeal; application dismissed.
Criminal procedure
— Extension of time to appeal — good cause — s361(2) Criminal Procedure Act
— Notice of Intention to Appeal — Notice of intention to appeal within 10 days — s 361(1)(a) CPA
Evidence — hearsay in affidavits — unauthorised third‑party information in an affidavit is inadmissible and lacks evidential value
2 April 2025
March 2025
Summary judgment granted against employer for unpaid NSSF contributions and penalties after failure to seek leave to defend.
Civil procedure — Summary judgment
Contract law — Labour/social security — Employer statutory contributions — Liability for unpaid NSSF members' contributions and penalties — Proof by registration details and contribution schedules
26 March 2025
An extension order under section 44 LLA is self-contained and binds the applicant; appeal dismissed.
Civil procedure — declaration of title — court grants reliefs pleaded
Civil procedure — Procedural law
— extension order is self-contained
— request letters cannot enlarge scope without specific particulars
Evidence — documents (exhibit PE-3) evaluation
Limitation law — Ministerial extension of time
21 March 2025
Appellate court re-evaluated omitted defence, upheld theft conviction and five-year sentence due to unchallenged prosecution evidence.
Criminal law — Theft — sufficiency of prosecution evidence — possession and admission
Criminal procedure
— Judgment formalities — omission as curable
— plea of not guilty — no duty to probe reasons for plea
— Right to be heard — trial court’s failure to address defence in judgment requires appellate re-evaluation
21 March 2025
Victim’s credible testimony, corroborated by witnesses and medical evidence, upheld rape conviction and sentence.
Criminal law — Rape — Proof beyond reasonable doubt
— admissibility despite minor timing inconsistencies
— Victim’s testimony as primary evidence corroborated by witnesses and medical report (PF3)
Criminal procedure — Judgment requirements — substantive compliance and curability under s.388 CPA
21 March 2025
Summary judgment granted for unpaid statutory NSSF contributions and penalties after defendant failed to seek leave to defend.
Civil procedure
— Remedies — interest at court rate and costs awarded on summary judgment
— Summary judgment — Order XXXV CPC
Contract law — Social security — employer obligation to remit employee and employer NSSF contributions — recovery of unpaid contributions and statutory penalties
21 March 2025
Summary judgment granted to recover unpaid statutory pension contributions and penalties with interest and costs.
Summary procedure — Order XXXV CPC — Recovery of statutory social security contributions — s.74A(2) NSSF Act — Defendant's failure to obtain leave to defend — Allegations deemed admitted — Summary judgment, interest and costs.
14 March 2025
Failure by a successor chairperson to record and communicate reasons for taking over hearing vitiated DLHT proceedings; retrial ordered.
Civil procedure — succession of judges in partly heard trial — Requirement to record reasons for takeover — Rule 15 CPC (G.N. No. 760/2021)
Land disputes — Procedural irregularities vitiate tribunal proceedings — Irregular takeover vitiates subsequent proceedings — Remittal for rehearing and locus in quo visit
14 March 2025
Court upheld entry of not‑guilty plea on accused's refusal and found re‑institution under s91(3) CPA lawful, dismissing the appeal.
Criminal procedure
— Discharge — Re‑institution after discharge: requirement of sufficient evidence and commencement of hearing on first appearance — s 91(3) Criminal Procedure Act
— Plea-taking — When a plea is equivocal or refused the court should record a plea of not guilty and proceed — s 228(4) Criminal Procedure Act
— Prosecutorial discretion — Alleged abuse of prosecutorial power in re‑instituting charges and need to observe principles in the National Prosecution Service Act — National Prosecution Service Act (principles)
12 March 2025