High Court Corruption and Economic Crimes Division - 2021 July

4 judgments
  • Filters
  • Judges
  • Alphabet
Sort by:
4 judgments
Citation
Judgment date
July 2021
Appellant failed to prove prior mortgage or title; mortgagee lawfully auctioned the encumbered property; appeal dismissed.
Land law – mortgage – validity of mortgage and priority; capacity to pass title while property encumbered; auction by mortgagee under section 126(d) Land Act; burden of proof – section 110 Evidence Act; appellate interference with tribunal findings; evidential weight – Hemedi Said v Mohamedi Mbilu.
30 July 2021
Prosecution failed to prove drug charges due to broken chain of custody and a defective cautioned statement.
* Criminal law – Drugs – Trafficking and possession – requirement to prove chain of custody from seizure to laboratory analysis – unexplained delay and missing handing-over documentation undermining admissibility and reliability of exhibits. * Criminal procedure – Cautioned statement – statutory requirements for reading, certification and timing – non-compliance renders statement unreliable.
27 July 2021
An application to restore a dismissed suit filed after the court-ordered deadline without leave was time-barred and dismissed with costs.
* Civil procedure – Restoration of dismissed suit – Compliance with court-ordered deadline – Filing after court-imposed date without leave is incompetent and time-barred. * Court orders – Time limits fixed by court – Parties must obey orders to ensure efficient administration of justice. * Preliminary objection – Time bar – Dismissal with costs where application filed out of time and without leave.
13 July 2021
Land claim dismissed as time‑barred: cause of action accrued in 2003; 12‑year limitation expired before suit.
* Limitation of actions – Land – Item 22 Part I Schedule to the Law of Limitation Act – 12‑year period for recovery of land – accrual of cause of action determined by pleadings and annexures. * Pleadings – plaint read with annexures to ascertain when plaintiff became aware of dispute. * Revocation of right of occupancy – effect on third parties and need to prove title against grantee before pursuit of claim against State.
6 July 2021