High Court Corruption and Economic Crimes Division - 2023 June

3 judgments
  • Filters
  • Judges
  • Alphabet
Sort by:
3 judgments
Citation
Judgment date
June 2023
Court forfeited certain properties acquired within ten years post‑conviction; other assets discharged for insufficient proof.
* Proceeds of Crime – conviction‑based forfeiture – statutory presumption for properties acquired/developed within ten years under Drugs Control Act – burden to rebut by reasonable explanation. * Standard of proof – balance of probabilities; need for particularised evidence of acquisition, development, timing and control. * Admissibility – affidavits by authorized officers relying on investigation files not automatically hearsay. * Third‑party titles – cannot be forfeited absent proof of respondent’s control or beneficial interest. * Jurisdiction – pending review at Court of Appeal does not preclude High Court post‑conviction forfeiture proceedings.
30 June 2023
Prosecution failed to prove trafficking where key witnesses were absent and an uncautioned oral confession lacked corroboration.
* Narcotic drugs – trafficking – burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt; quality of evidence over number of witnesses. * Non‑production of key witnesses – adverse inference where absent witnesses could have supplied decisive evidence. * Oral confession to police – requirement of cautioning and need for corroboration; received with great caution. * Chain of custody/possession – need to prove accused drove or had control of vehicle (driving licence, ownership).
13 June 2023
Court convicted accused of trafficking, finding lawful searches, proven possession and sufficient chain of custody.
Criminal law – narcotic drugs – search and seizure under Cr.P.C. s.38 and DCEA s.32(5); possession and constructive possession; chain of custody – oral proof versus documentary paper trail; alibi—statutory notice requirements (Cap.200 s.42); role and significance of independent witnesses; admissibility and weight of exhibits (certificates of seizure, laboratory analysis).
7 June 2023