|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| August 2022 |
|
|
Failure to comply with statutory land disposition formalities renders an alleged sale void and occupant a trespasser.
Land — Disposition/transfer of Right of Occupancy — Requirement of registration and Commissioner’s approval (Land Act ss.36–40); Registration of Documents Act and Land Registration Act — unregistered agreement not effecting transfer; Certificate of approval — procedural formalities and payment of premia/taxes; Occupation prior to statutory compliance — trespass; Reliefs — vacant possession, damages, costs.
|
22 August 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed: Ward Tribunal met statutory quorum; the presence of only two women did not vitiate proceedings.
Ward Tribunals — composition and quorum — statutory quorum (one half of total members) — requirement of female members — whether shortfall invalidates proceedings — appellate review of concurrent tribunal findings.
|
22 August 2022 |
|
Applicant failed to account for delay; court expunged defective affidavit paragraphs and dismissed the application with costs.
Civil procedure – extension of time – requirement to account for each day of delay – sufficient cause.* Affidavit practice – affidavits must state facts not legal argument or conclusions – offensive paragraphs may be expunged if inconsequential.* Verification and filing – counter-affidavit properly verified and filed within time where service shown on record.* Appeals from DLHT – governed by s.38 Land Disputes Courts Act (60 days) and no need to await certified copies before filing appeal.
|
20 August 2022 |
|
Preliminary objections on death, limitation, cause of action and non-joinder were overruled; factual issues reserved for trial.
Land law – preliminary objections – suit alleged against deceased defendant: death is evidential not a pure point of law; substitution under Order 1 r.10(2) CPC; Limitation – whether cause of action arose is factual and requires evidence (Law of Limitation Act s.3(1)); Cause of action – plaint must be read on its face to determine sufficiency (Byombalirwa definition); Non-joinder – misjoinder/non-joinder not fatal; court may order joinder (Order 1 r.9 CPC).
|
19 August 2022 |
|
An appellate tribunal must quash proceedings when the trial court lacked jurisdiction due to lack of locus standi.
Land law – locus standi – jurisdictional effect of lack of locus standi; Civil procedure – appellate duty to quash trial proceedings where plaintiff lacks locus standi; Revision – section 43(1)(b) Land Disputes Courts Act – availability where party now sues in different capacity (administratrix); Nullity – proceedings null ab initio where instituted by incompetent person.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Court allowed injunction application despite expiry of statutory notice because the matter was pending before the court.
Civil procedure – temporary (Mareva) injunction – requirements under Atilio v Mbowe – balance of convenience and irreparable harm; Statutory notice of intention to sue – effect of expiry and when application may be overtaken by events; Sub judice principle – pendency of an application may justify allowing applicant opportunity to institute main suit.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Appellant's claim that suit land was public open space failed; survey evidence established 10.75m encroachment, appeal dismissed.
Land law – trespass/encroachment – municipal survey verification of beacons; ownership vs. public open space claims; locus standi in trespass disputes; evaluation of documentary and surveyor evidence (Exh P2) — appeal dismissed.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Court partly set aside taxed instruction fee where no proof counsel was instructed on the receipt date, leaving remaining costs intact.
Advocates Remuneration — taxation of costs — instruction (attendance) fees — awarding fees where matter withdrawn — effect of preliminary objection and defended proceedings — proof of service and authenticity of receipts.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Long occupation and family allocation established the defendant’s ownership; plaintiff’s delayed claim failed and suit dismissed.
Land law – ownership dispute – allocation by deceased and long occupation; evidentiary weight of family/clan meeting and token payment; omission from probate and acquiescence; remedy – dismissal for failure to prove title.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Review denied on merits but partly allowed to join the correct local authority instead of a misnamed village government.
Civil procedure — Review jurisdiction — Order XLII Rule 1 — Review limited to apparent errors on face of record; not a substitute for appeal — Correction of misidentified necessary party — Local authority to be joined, not Village Government of planned area.
|
19 August 2022 |
|
Applicant granted extension to file appeal due to delayed supply of certified judgment and decree; application filed promptly.
Land — Extension of time to file appeal — Delay caused by late supply of certified copies of judgment and decree — Sufficient cause for extension depends on circumstances — Prompt application after supply — Exercise of judicial discretion.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Applicant failed to show sufficient cause or account for over 50 days’ delay; extension of time dismissed with costs.
Civil procedure – Extension of time – Application under s.42(2) Land Disputes Courts Act and s.14(1) Law of Limitation Act – Applicant must account for each day of delay – Lyamuya guidelines applied – General claims (remoteness, financial difficulty, miscommunication, wrong registry) held insufficient.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Applicant failed to show a prima facie cause of action; interlocutory injunction dismissed for lack of triable issue.
Civil procedure – temporary injunction – prerequisites: prima facie case/triable issue, irreparable harm, balance of convenience. Land law – dispute over ownership – registered title vs alleged forged transfer documents. Interlocutory relief – absence of pending main suit or cause of action undermines grant of injunction. Allegations of forgery – ordinarily pursued through criminal investigation or substantive trial, not sufficient alone for interim relief
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Appellate court upheld tribunal’s credibility-based finding of ownership where no documentary proof of title existed, dismissing the appeal with costs.
Land law – proof of ownership – burden of proof and resolution by witness credibility where documentary title absent; credibility findings on appeal – appellate restraint; inadmissibility of cited ages/notations as proof of age; inheritance claims versus contractual-capacity authorities.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Court granted extension to appeal out of time where delay was technical and time runs from receipt of certified judgment copy.
Land law — Extension of time under s.41(2) Land Disputes Courts Act — Computation of limitation period excluding time to obtain judgment copies (s.19(2) Law of Limitation Act) — Technical delay excusable (Fortunatus Masha) — Judicial discretion and factors for extension.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Amended plaint exceeding the limited court-ordered leave and made without further leave was struck out, dismissing the suit with costs.
Civil procedure – Amendment of pleadings – Order VI Rule 17 CPC – Scope of leave to amend – Amendments exceeding court's leave and introducing/removing parties require fresh leave – Non-compliance with court order grounds for striking out amended plaint and suit.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Applicant restored suit after showing one sufficient cause (illness); affidavit-on-information disregarded; no order as to costs.
Civil procedure – setting aside dismissal for want of prosecution – applicant must show sufficient cause; Section 95 CPC vs Order IX r.5 – remedy by appeal if objection to provision; affidavits on information must disclose source; sickness may constitute sufficient cause to restore suit; restoration without costs where circumstances warrant.
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Failure to read assessors' opinions in open court vitiated the tribunal judgment, warranting quashing and retrial.
Land law – ownership dispute – possession and title evidence – valuation report probative value questioned but matter not determined on merits. Civil procedure – Land Disputes Courts (District Land and Housing Tribunal) Regulations – role of assessors – requirement that assessors’ written opinions be availed/read in presence of parties. Procedural irregularity – failure to read assessors’ opinions in open court vitiates tribunal judgment. Revisionary powers – invocation of section 43(1)(b) LDC Act to quash and remit for retrial
|
18 August 2022 |
|
Plaintiff failed to prove title; revocation and reallocation were lawful, suit dismissed and plaintiff ordered to pay costs.
Land law — proof of ownership of registered land — Letter of Offer and lost documents insufficient absent Certificate of Title; burden of proof; lawful revocation under Land Act s.45; validity of allocation and issuance of Certificate of Title.
|
17 August 2022 |
|
Electronic submission alone is not filing where fees are payable; filing date is when court fees are paid, so the appeal was time-barred.
Civil procedure – limitation – Land Disputes Courts Act s.41(2) – 45-day appeal period from District Land and Housing Tribunal decisions
Electronic Filing Rules (GN No.148/2018) – Rule 21(1) and Rule 22 – electronic submission vs. completion of filing. Date of filing where court fees payable – filing deemed complete on payment of court fees. Preliminary objection – inadmissibility of extraneous evidence at preliminary objection stage; Mukisa principle. Application of Law of Limitation Act s.3(1), s.43 and s.46 where other statute prescribes limitation remedy
|
17 August 2022 |
|
Court granted interlocutory injunction against demolition pending trial, finding triable issue, irreparable loss and balance of convenience favor applicants.
Land law – Interim injunction pending trial – Requirements for temporary injunction: serious triable issue, irreparable loss, balance of convenience – Long possession and development as evidence of irreparable harm – Non-joinder and public interest considerations.
|
17 August 2022 |
|
Revision of an interlocutory tribunal order was incompetent and struck out; matter remitted to the tribunal.
Land disputes — Revision of tribunal orders — Interlocutory vs final orders — Section 79(2) Civil Procedure Code bars revision of interlocutory decisions — Section 13(4) Ward Tribunal referral requirement — Competence of revision under Land Disputes Courts Act.
|
16 August 2022 |
|
Failure to record and read assessors' opinions rendered the tribunal's judgment null and required remittal for rehearing.
Land law – procedure – assessors' opinions must be in writing and recorded; omission is fundamental irregularity rendering tribunal judgment unsafe and subject to rehearing; issue of double allocation and locus in quo not determined due to procedural defect.
|
16 August 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed: tribunal properly found respondent's ownership; non-joinder and survey-consent complaints were unavailing.
Land law — ownership dispute over unsurveyed parcel — party adducing title preferred where opponents fail to produce documentary proof; Civil procedure — non-joinder — necessary party test; afterthought for first time on appeal; Survey law — no consent required where land is shown to be unsurveyed; Evidence — trial court entitled to prefer oral and documentary evidence of possessor; contradictions not material.
|
16 August 2022 |
|
Court dismissed preliminary objection to improperly titled appeal, allowed amendment under overriding objective, costs to be borne by each party.
Civil procedure – Preliminary objection – Form of instituting document – Order XXXIX Rule 1(1) CPC – Overriding objective (section 3A CPC) – Amendment of defective pleadings – Defect not going to root of matter – Costs each party bears own.
|
15 August 2022 |
|
Appeal dismissed: respondents proved ownership; sale nullified as vendor lacked title and evidential support.
Land law – ownership proof – burden of proof under section 110 of the Evidence Act – oral evidence and corroboration. Transfer of land – sale void where vendor lacks title – evidential value of sale agreements. Possession and limitation – long absence (over 12 years) and its effect on recovery of land. Civil procedure – assessment of weight of evidence in land disputes; damages not awarded without proof
|
15 August 2022 |
|
Failure to prove wakf ownership and lack of trustee locus resulted in dismissal of the land claim.
Land law – Wakf property – Evidential value of wakf documents; locus standi – who may sue as trustees; admissibility and weight of letters, photographs and invitations; role and recording of assessors’ opinions in Tribunal proceedings; standard of proof being balance of probabilities.
|
15 August 2022 |
|
Appellate tribunal misapprehension of evidence warranted reversal; trial tribunal’s finding of eight-acre ownership restored with costs.
Land law – title to land – appellate review of factual findings; credibility of witnesses; no fixed number of witnesses required; standard of proof – balance of probabilities; denial of hearing and procedural non-compliance.
|
15 August 2022 |
|
Whether a prescriptive public right of way was established; court found insufficient evidence and allowed the appellant's appeal.
Land law – right of way/prescriptive easement – requirements of 20 years’ uninterrupted use under s.31 Law of Limitation Act – evidential proof and sale documents; locus in quo – procedural requirements and weight of observations; failure to call material witness – adverse inference; role and competency of assessors.
|
14 August 2022 |
|
Application for extension of time dismissed: illness, counsel’s negligence and non‑apparent illegality insufficient to justify delay.
Extension of time—section 11(1) AJA; Lyamuya guidelines—accounting for delay, inordinate delay, diligence; illness as cause—medical evidence must account for whole period; alleged illegality must be apparent on the face of the record; negligence or bad advice of counsel not a sufficient cause.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Appellant failed to prove ownership; tribunal’s order to sell the family house was quashed and respondents declared lawful owners.
Evidence – burden of proof where a person is shown in possession – s.119 Evidence Act; Probate – letters of administration appoint administrator do not automatically vest ownership or decide title to specific property; Civil procedure – tribunal’s order to sell property must be supported by evidence and by relief prayed; Res judicata – probate appointment does not necessarily adjudicate title on a competent court’s jurisdictional limits.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Failure to record presiding ward tribunal members vitiates proceedings; retrial must follow post-2021 mediation and referral procedure.
Civil procedure – Land disputes – Ward tribunal proceedings must record presiding members on each sitting; omission vitiates proceedings. Appellate review – First appellate tribunal nullifying proceedings should avoid determining merits to prevent prejudice to retrial. Statutory amendment – Written Laws (Miscellaneous Amendments) (No.3) Act, 2021: ward tribunals limited to mediation (30 days), referral to DLHT for adjudication; retrial must follow amended procedure or parties may file fresh suit
Jurisdiction – Pecuniary jurisdiction issues may require fresh proceedings in a competent court when value is not stated
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Successor chairman's unexplained takeover and judgment pronounced without notice nullified the tribunal's decision and remitted the file for rehearing.
Land procedure — Succession of tribunal chair — successor must assign reasons for takeover; failure vitiates proceedings; Judgment — must be pronounced in open court with notice to parties; absence of notice renders judgment null; Consequence — nullification of proceedings and remittal for fresh judgment.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
A successor tribunal chairman must assign reasons for takeover and judgment pronounced without notice is invalid.
Civil procedure – succession of judicial officer – requirement that successor assign reasons when taking over partly heard matter (Order XVII Rule 10(c) CPC). Civil procedure – pronouncement of judgment – requirement of notice and presence of parties (Order XX Rule 1 CPC). Procedural irregularities – failure to assign reasons and delivery of judgment without notice vitiate proceedings and lead to nullification and remittal
|
12 August 2022 |
|
The plaintiff's suit was struck out for failure to join the purchaser as a necessary party.
Civil procedure – Preliminary objections – Non-joinder of necessary party (purchaser at auction) – Suit improperly constituted – Striking out plaint with costs; Verification clause objection not determined.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
A prior notice of appeal at the Court of Appeal bars trial court jurisdiction and warrants striking out an identical subsequent suit.
Civil procedure – res subjudice – effect of notice of intention/notice of appeal lodged at the Court of Appeal – section 8 Civil Procedure Code – trial court loses jurisdiction over identical subject matter – striking out suit – costs.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Unsubstantiated travels and illness did not establish good cause for extension to file bill of costs.
Extension of time – application under Section 14 Law of Limitation Act – requirement to show good cause and account for each day of delay; Evidence – necessity of credible supporting documents and sworn supplementary affidavit when relying on advocate’s incapacity/attendance; Illness – valid ground only if causally connected to failure to act in time; Bill of costs – must be filed within 60 days of judgment unless extension granted.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Defendants held lawful ownership; plaintiffs’ survey-derived titles invalidated due to defective antecedent sale documents.
Land law – proof of ownership: adequacy and admissibility of sale agreements; importance of pleading and calling material witnesses; village allocation certificates as evidence; adverse inference for withheld evidence; validity of post-survey certificates of title.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
A completed sale to a bonafide purchaser is protected despite auction procedural irregularities; mortgagor's remedy is damages.
Land law – mortgagee’s power of sale – authority to sell on borrower default; Auctioneers Act notice requirements; Land Act ss. 127, 133, 135 – definition and protection of bonafide purchaser; procedural irregularities do not annul completed sale to bonafide purchaser; remedy for mortgagor is damages against mortgagee/agent.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Appellant’s late challenge to framed issues and acreage failed; uncontroverted sale agreements established respondents' ownership, appeal dismissed with costs.
Civil procedure – framing of issues – Order XIV Rule 5(1) CPC – issues framed after parties' participation; objection on appeal held to be afterthought
Evidence – weight and credibility – uncontroverted sale agreements and local leaders’ testimony outweigh inconsistent claimant’s evidence. Land law – trespass – claim requires established ownership; cannot trespass on one’s own land
|
12 August 2022 |
|
A preliminary objection alleging res judicata and functus officio fails where earlier proceedings were not finally decided on the merits.
Civil procedure — Preliminary objection — Mukisa Biscuit test — objection must raise a pure point of law without need for evidence. Res judicata — five conditions (same matter, same parties/privity, same title, competent court, finally decided on merits) must co-exist. Functus officio — court becomes functus only where prior matter was heard and finally decided on the merits. Judicial notice — Evidence Act ss.58–59; court will not take judicial notice of proceedings not pleaded or exhibited. Matrimonial property disputes — challenge based on lack of spouse consent/fraud may differ from prior challenges to mortgage/auction
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Application attacking execution struck out because a pending appeal on the same execution bars concurrent High Court determination.
Land law and civil procedure – Execution proceedings – Presence of a Notice of Appeal to the Court of Appeal challenging the execution – Effect on High Court jurisdiction and concurrent proceedings – multiplicity of suits – Order XXI Rules 57(1), 58 and section 95 CPC.
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Decision from objection proceedings is final; aggrieved party must institute a fresh suit, not seek revision.
Execution and objection proceedings – Order XXI, Rules 57–62 CPC – Order on objection proceedings is conclusive – remedy is to institute a fresh suit under Order XXI Rule 62 – no appeal or revision available. Revisional jurisdiction – cannot be invoked where alternative statutory remedy exists and has not been exhausted
|
12 August 2022 |
|
Appellant failed to prove joint ownership; tribunal properly evaluated evidence and assessors' opinions, appeal dismissed.
Land disputes – ownership – evidential weight of title deeds and sale agreements; assessment of witness inconsistency; obligation to record reasons when differing from assessors; validity of judicial re-assignment.
|
11 August 2022 |
|
Appellate court upheld release of property from attachment where third party purchased and occupied it and affidavit defects were non‑prejudicial.
Land execution – attachment of property – objection to attachment – Regulation 22 of Land Disputes Courts Regulations v Order XXI/CPC; competency of affidavits/jurat – non-prejudicial technical defects; possession and title – actual occupation and prior sale; execution against property of third party – release from attachment.
|
11 August 2022 |
|
Appellant failed to prove title or establish bias; appeal dismissed and no order as to costs.
Land law – proof of title: claimant must tender documentary or witness evidence to prove transfer or will; Procedural fairness – alleged interest or bias of tribunal member must be raised and evidenced at trial; Appellate review – appellate courts will affirm findings where trial record lacks proof; Failure to prosecute a ground on appeal amounts to abandonment.
|
11 August 2022 |
|
An Order XXI Rule 57(1) application is premature without actual attachment and is struck out with costs.
Civil Procedure - Order XXI Rule 57(1) CPC - objection to attachment - requirement of actual attachment before investigation - premature application - remedy of release under Order XXI Rule 59 - striking out with costs.
|
11 August 2022 |
|
Failure to have assessors give and have their written opinions read in parties' presence renders the tribunal’s judgment null and void.
Land procedure – assessors’ participation – Regulation 19(2) DLT Regulations – assessors must give written opinions at conclusion of hearing and such opinions must be availed/read in parties’ presence; non‑compliance is fatal. Trial de novo ordered where tribunal judgment made without assessors’ opinions being given in presence of parties
|
11 August 2022 |
|
Leave to appeal granted because the proposed grounds disclose arguable points of law; substantive issues not decided.
Land law – Leave to appeal – Discretionary grant where grounds disclose prima facie/arguable or novel point of law; court granting leave must not decide substantive issues; preliminary objection on competency withdrawn; no costs ordered due to legal aid.
|
11 August 2022 |
|
Appellant who bought 3.5 acres earlier holds superior title; later purchasers could not acquire valid interest under nemo dat.
Land law – ownership dispute – priority of title – nemo dat quod non habet; evidence – evaluation of sale agreements and oral testimony; failure of subsequent purchasers to prove title; admissibility and sufficiency of sale agreements without photographs.
|
11 August 2022 |