|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| June 2024 |
|
|
On appeal the court re-evaluated evidence and found the appellant's title credible, quashing the tribunal's judgment.
Land law – ownership dispute; Civil procedure – compliance with Rule 20(1) GN 174/2003 and Order XX rule 4; Appellate review – first appellate court re-evaluating evidence where trial tribunal failed to analyze testimony and documents; Evidence – authenticity of sale agreements and signatures.
|
20 June 2024 |
|
Suing a party in the wrong (personal) capacity vitiated the land proceedings and required amendment and retrial.
Land disputes — mandatory Ward Tribunal mediation under section 13, Land Disputes Courts Act — sufficiency of attached mediation certificate; civil procedure — misjoinder/wrong party — suing a person in wrong capacity (personal vs representative) may vitiate proceedings and require quashing and retrial; amendment of pleadings; remittal for trial de novo.
|
20 June 2024 |
|
Misjoinder by suing an administratix personally vitiated DLHT proceedings despite an attached mediation certificate.
Land law – mandatory Ward Tribunal mediation certificate – attachment of certificate as sufficient proof where mediation is undisputed; Civil procedure – joinder and capacity – suing a person in personal rather than representative capacity may vitiate proceedings; Remedy – quashing proceedings and remittal for trial de novo.
|
20 June 2024 |
|
Appeal allowed: title deed name and representative-capacity discrepancies vitiated Tribunal proceedings; decision quashed.
Land law – ownership dispute – identity and capacity on Title/Certificate of Occupancy; Evidence – admissibility and reliance on documents with name variations; Locus standi – unclear legal representation vitiating proceedings; Civil procedure – expungement of late submissions and ex parte hearing.
|
20 June 2024 |
|
Tribunal lawfully exercised jurisdiction; auction and purchaser's title upheld and the appellant's challenges dismissed with costs.
Land law – mortgage and sale by public auction – notice of default and notice of sale – bona fide purchaser. Civil procedure – pecuniary jurisdiction of District Land and Housing Tribunal (section 33(2)(a)) – valuation evidence. Civil procedure – effect of unpleaded pending appeal/res judicata – requirement to plead and prove. Civil procedure – clerical error in judgment/cause number – rectification under section 95 of Civil Procedure Code
|
20 June 2024 |
|
Improper consolidation of separate cases with different parties and causes renders the tribunal’s judgment null and void.
Land law; consolidation of proceedings — consolidation requires same nature, similar issues and same parties; improper consolidation of different applications with different parties and causes; lack of proof identity of parties; effect: nullification and quashing of tribunal judgment.
|
19 June 2024 |
|
A land ownership claim was dismissed as time‑barred and barred by res judicata; costs awarded against the plaintiff.
Limitation of actions – land – statutory limitation period for recovery of land is twelve years; failure to plead grounds for extension bars suit.* Res judicata – previous adjudication on ownership by Ward Tribunal and dismissal of appeal prevents rehearing of same cause of action.* Pre‑court negotiations do not stop or suspend running of limitation.* Impleading state authorities does not defeat res judicata or cure limitation bar.
|
19 June 2024 |
|
Failure to copy the Solicitor General with the 90‑day notice and not appealing the Registrar’s act led to striking out the suit.
Government Proceedings Act s6(2) — mandatory service of 90‑day notice and copy to Solicitor General; Land Registration Act ss101–102 — Registrar's acts/decisions to be challenged by appeal; failure to serve Solicitor General and instituting fresh suit instead of appeal is fatal.
|
19 June 2024 |
|
|
19 June 2024 |
|
Failure to record locus in quo observations and to identify which apartment was auctioned caused a miscarriage of justice; trial decision quashed.
Land law – ownership dispute between adjacent units on same floor; locus in quo – procedural requirements and necessity to record observations; evidence – identification of property and evaluation of competing title deeds; admissibility – late objections on exhibits; expert witnesses – no mandatory duty to summon; procedure – Regulation 12 non-compliance not fatal where no miscarriage of justice.
|
19 June 2024 |
|
Appellant failed to prove ownership of the disputed house; tribunal rightly applied burden of proof and upheld prior matrimonial finding.
Land law – ownership of house within registered plot – burden of proof under s.110 Evidence Act – need for documentary evidence (sale agreement, TRA assignment) when land ownership contested; Matrimonial judgment binding on subsequent tribunal – District Land and Housing Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to overturn Ilala District Court’s matrimonial division absent appellate/revisional order; Identity of property in will must be clear to be probative; Limitation and jurisdictional complaints rejected where appellant instituted suit.
|
19 June 2024 |
|
|
18 June 2024 |
|
|
18 June 2024 |
|
Proceedings conducted by an advocate without a valid practising certificate are void and warrant retrial.
Advocates Act – practising certificate – representation by an advocate without a current practising certificate renders acts and proceedings void. Overriding objective/Article 107A(1)(c) – cannot cure fundamental illegality of unqualified representation. Civil procedure – nullity of proceedings – retrial ordered before a different Chairperson
|
18 June 2024 |
|
Temporary injunction refused: prima facie ownership dispute found but no irreparable harm shown; application dismissed with no costs.
Civil procedure – interim injunctions – application for status quo ante under Order XXXVII r.1(a) of the Civil Procedure Act; application of Atilio v Mbowe test: prima facie case, irreparable harm, balance of convenience. Possession/ownership disputes – alleged trespass and eviction of tenants do not necessarily constitute irreparable injury warranting interim relief
|
14 June 2024 |
|
Earlier-registered title upheld; alleged revocation not proved; later title declared illegally issued, trespass and compensation awarded.
Land law – Competing registered titles; priority to earlier registered title where later title not lawfully justified; revocation of right of occupancy — statutory notice, service and publication requirements; burden of proof on party alleging revocation; possession, development and demolition — entitlement to compensation; rectification of land register where title illegally issued.
|
14 June 2024 |
|
Extension of time granted where tribunal’s failure to supply certified ruling caused delay and applicant acted diligently.
Extension of time – application under Order 8(1) Advocates Remuneration Order – Lyamuya guidelines – delay attributable to tribunal’s failure to supply certified copies – diligence of applicant – extension granted.
|
14 June 2024 |
|
Concession to a preliminary objection admitting procedural defect renders the suit incompetent and liable to be struck out.
Civil procedure — Preliminary objection under Order VII r.1(e) CPC — Concession to objection — Admission of incompetence — Suit struck out — Costs awarded.
|
13 June 2024 |
|
An applicant must plead and prove title with adequate descriptions and witnesses; courts must not grant unclaimed relief.
Land law – burden of proof (s.110 Evidence Act) – requirement to call material witnesses – adverse inference for failure to call vendors – unsurveyed land must be sufficiently described in pleadings – parties bound by pleadings – court cannot grant relief not pleaded – evidential weight of unadmitted documents and locus in quo/site visit.
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Applicant's counsel travel-related illness and a technical filing delay warranted setting aside the dismissal order.
Civil procedure – setting aside dismissal for want of prosecution – excuses of counsel’s travel and sudden illness – sufficiency and rebuttal of evidence
Extension of time – delay caused by procedural call for additional information – technical delay versus negligence
Exercise of discretion and overriding objective (CPC ss. 3A, 3B) in restoring matters dismissed for want of prosecution
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Appeal allowed: tribunal’s decision quashed for violating right to be heard by introducing locus standi suo motu.
Natural justice – right to be heard (audi alteram partem) – tribunal raising locus standi suo motu – procedural irregularity – untendered/unsworn evidence – decision a nullity and remit for proper hearing.
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Nonjoinder of the seller and auctioneer rendered the land tribunal proceedings null and void; the decision was quashed.
Land law – necessary parties – seller and auctioneer as indispensable parties where land was sold at public auction following loan default. Civil procedure – nonjoinder – proceedings conducted without necessary parties are null and void and court lacks competence to pronounce effective decree
Land Disputes Courts Act s.43 – High Court’s power to nullify/quash Tribunal proceedings for jurisdictional defects
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Whether the defendant’s counsel’s claims of past professional conflict and scheduling justify judicial recusal.
Judicial recusal – disqualification criteria under Rule 9 GN
No.1001/2020 – necessity of factual basis for alleged bias or personal interest. Conflict of interest – distinction between hostility towards the law/public prosecution and personal animus towards a judge. Case management – public policy favouring finality of litigation and court control of its calendar. Counsel conduct – withdrawing or threatening withdrawal does not compel judicial recusal
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Court upheld taxing officer's instruction-fee discretion but reduced attendance and disbursement awards on reference.
Taxation of costs – Reference under Rule 7(1), Advocates Remuneration Order, 2015 – Instruction fees – taxing officer’s discretion and Premchand principles; Attendance fees – application of Item 3(a) 8th Schedule (Tshs.50,000 per 15 minutes appearance); Disbursements – proof by receipts not always required but quantum must be reasonable; Court’s limited intervention in taxing officer’s exercise of discretion.
|
12 June 2024 |
|
Specific Land Registration Act appeal regime displaces general Government Proceedings Act; Solicitor General wrongly joined.
Administrative law – appeals from Registrar of Titles under Land Registration Act (s.102) – Specific statutory appeal regime displaces general Government Proceedings Act; Government Proceedings Act (s.6) mandatory but general; joinder of Attorney General not required under s.102; Solicitor General wrongly joined.
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Appellants entitled to ten plots; absence of pleaded spousal consent did not void the agreement without supporting evidence.
Land law – disposition of land and spousal consent; pleadings principle – parties bound by their pleadings; contract law – validity of agreement, void v. voidable, enforcement of freely agreed contractual terms; appellate review – re-evaluation of evidence and misdirection by trial tribunal.
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Suit struck out for non-joinder of necessary parties; court exercised discretion and ordered no costs.
Civil procedure – Non-joinder of necessary parties – Suit struck out for failure to join Tanzania Investment Centre and Registrar of Titles. Civil procedure – Preliminary objections – withdrawal and concession by plaintiff to expedite substantive justice
Costs – Discretion under section 30(1) Civil Procedure Code – costs not automatic; considered in light of parties’ conduct
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Whether the plaintiff acquires good title where a prior default judgment nullified the vendor's title and administrator lacked capacity.
Land law — administrators of an estate — validity of sale by one co-administrator; Effect of a prior default judgment declaring a sale illegal — nemo dat rule; Bona fide purchaser doctrine — searches, notice and entitlement to restitution versus title; Remedies — dismissal of ownership claim, refund, restraining order, no costs.
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Eviction upheld as lawful where the applicant breached sale and lease obligations by failing to pay required sums.
Land law – lease and sale agreement; existence of contract for sale despite title not yet transferred; tenant’s failure to pay agreed initial deposit; breach of lease for unpaid rent; lawful re-entry and eviction under lease clause permitting termination after 60 days’ non-payment.
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Repeal of appellate provisions did not extinguish pre-repeal appeals; District Tribunal retained jurisdiction and matter remitted for merits.
Land law – jurisdiction – effect of repeal of statutory appellate provisions – whether repeal of Sections 20 and 21, Land Disputes Courts Act, extinguishes pre-existing appeals; Interpretation of Laws Act s.32 – repeal does not affect prior operations, rights or proceedings; remittal to tribunal for merits hearing.
|
11 June 2024 |
|
Applicant conceded incompetence; court struck out the application for lack of jurisdiction and awarded costs to respondents.
Civil procedure – preliminary objection – jurisdiction – where application is defective or incompetent the court must determine preliminary objection first; incompetent application cannot be withdrawn to pre-empt PO; remedy is striking out rather than dismissal
Costs – discretion of court; costs ordinarily follow the event where respondents incurred expenses litigating PO
|
10 June 2024 |
|
Non‑joinder of municipal authority who changed the title renders land proceedings null; decision quashed and fresh suit permitted.
Land law – Necessary party and non‑joinder – Municipal council that effected change of name on residential licence is a necessary party; non‑joinder renders proceedings incompetent and a nullity. Revisionary jurisdiction – Court may revise and quash proceedings where necessary parties were omitted
Remedy – Quash decision and allow fresh suit with necessary parties included
|
7 June 2024 |
|
Court granted extension to file revision after finding technical delay explained and permitting amendment of the respondent’s title.
Extension of time – s.14(1) Law of Limitation Act – discretion and Lyamuya factors (account for delay; inordinate delay; diligence; illegality). Amendment of parties – misnomer/omission of respondent’s capacity – curable under overriding objective and Cropper principle. Technical vs actual delay – objection proceedings and prompt action as evidence of diligence. Illegality of impugned judgment (insufficient property description) raised but not determined
|
7 June 2024 |
|
High Court lacks jurisdiction to hear committal for alleged breach while appeal and stay application are pending in the Court of Appeal.
Civil procedure — Jurisdiction — Lodging notice of appeal divests High Court of jurisdiction over connected matters; pending stay of execution at Court of Appeal bars High Court from entertaining committal for alleged breach of Court of Appeal order.
|
5 June 2024 |
|
Appellate court dismissed challenge to the sale, upholding purchaser’s title despite procedural defects raised belatedly.
Land law – ownership dispute – validity and admissibility of a sale agreement; effect of absence of stamp duty
Evidence – late objections to documentary evidence on appeal treated as afterthoughts; oral evidence and corroboration can sustain title finding. Family/matrimonial interests – spousal consent to disposition of land: requirement must be pleaded and proved
Probate/administration – necessity of letters of administration to establish capacity to sue or be sued
|
4 June 2024 |
|
Application for temporary injunction dismissed because the lease had expired, so no prima facie entitlement to relief.
Interim injunctions – Atilio v. Mbowe test – prima facie case – expired lease defeats entitlement to interlocutory injunctive relief; balance of convenience and irreparable harm not reached once prima facie case fails
|
4 June 2024 |
|
Partial temporary injunction granted preventing eviction of one apartment pending trial; injunction overtaken for apartments already handed over.
Civil procedure – Temporary injunction – Order XXXVIII Rule 1 – Atilio test: prima facie case, irreparable injury, balance of convenience. Possession and eviction – Whether application for injunction is overtaken by events where properties already handed over to third parties
Securities – lender's alternative securities and effect on balance of convenience. Defaulting respondents – effect of non‑opposition on injunction application
|
3 June 2024 |
|
Partial temporary injunction granted: eviction restrained for one apartment pending trial; other units overtaken by execution.
Land law – temporary injunction – Order XXXVIII CPC and Atilio v Mbowe triad (prima facie case, irreparable injury, balance of convenience) – partial injunction where some properties already handed over (overtaken by events).
|
3 June 2024 |
|
Time spent prosecuting a prior incompetent suit is excluded under s.21(1), so the land recovery suit was not time-barred.
Limitation of actions – Law of Limitation Act Cap 89 R.E. 2019 – s.21(1) – exclusion of time spent prosecuting another civil proceeding prosecuted with due diligence where prior court was incompetent for want of geographical jurisdiction – effect on time bar for recovery of land; preliminary objection – consideration limited to facts pleaded in the plaint.
|
3 June 2024 |
|
Priority principle applies only when claimants derive title from the same vendor; claimant must prove the chain of title.
Land law – ownership of un-surveyed land; priority principle (qui prior est tempore, potior est jure) – scope and limitation where claimants derive title from different vendors; burden of proof under section 110(1) Evidence Act; locus in quo visitation discretionary and only required where boundaries or location are genuinely contested.
|
3 June 2024 |
|
Court entered consent judgment enforcing instalment schedule for rent arrears and ordered each party to bear its own costs.
Land law – rent arrears – summary suit under Order XXXV – consent judgment – Deed of Settlement recorded as court order – instalment payment schedule – execution on default – costs each party to bear own.
|
3 June 2024 |